Skip to content

A 3D Printed Ready-Mixed Concrete Power-Distribution Substation (2019-05)

Materials and Construction Technology

10.3390/ma12091540

Ji Guangchao,  Ding Tao,  Xiao Jianzhuang, Du Shupeng,  Li Jun,  Duan Zhenhua
Journal Article - Materials, Vol. 12, Iss. 9

Abstract

Currently, 3D concrete printing technology is not yet able to print ready-mixed concrete with coarse aggregates. Based on an independently developed 3D printing construction equipment system and optimized concrete materials, a 3D concrete printer that can directly print ready-mixed concrete is developed. This paper introduces the whole 3D printing process for one power distribution substation in detail, including the printing equipment, key software, concrete preparation, printing process, and construction inspection. This investigation will provide valuable design and construction experience for the future construction of 3D concrete printing.

20 References

  1. Bosscher Paul, Williams Robert, Bryson L., Castro-Lacouture Daniel (2007-04)
    Cable-Suspended Robotic Contour Crafting System
  2. Cesaretti Giovanni, Dini Enrico, Kestelier Xavier, Colla Valentina et al. (2013-08)
    Building Components for an Outpost on the Lunar Soil by Means of a Novel 3D Printing Technology
  3. Feng Peng, Meng Xinmiao, Chen Jian-Fei, Ye Lieping (2015-06)
    Mechanical Properties of Structures 3D Printed with Cementitious Powders
  4. Gosselin Clément, Duballet Romain, Roux Philippe, Gaudillière-Jami Nadja et al. (2016-03)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing of Ultra-High-Performance Concrete:
    A New Processing Route for Architects and Builders
  5. Hambach Manuel, Volkmer Dirk (2017-02)
    Properties of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Portland-Cement-Paste
  6. Kazemian Ali, Yuan Xiao, Cochran Evan, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2017-04)
    Cementitious Materials for Construction-Scale 3D Printing:
    Laboratory Testing of Fresh Printing Mixture
  7. Khalil Noura, Aouad Georges, Cheikh Khadija, Rémond Sébastien (2017-09)
    Use of Calcium-Sulfoaluminate-Cements for Setting-Control of 3D Printing Mortars
  8. Khoshnevis Behrokh, Dutton Rosanne (1998-01)
    Innovative Rapid Prototyping Process Makes Large-Sized, Smooth-Surfaced Complex Shapes in a Wide Variety of Materials
  9. Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
    Hardened Properties of High-Performance Printing Concrete
  10. Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
    Mix-Design and Fresh Properties for High-Performance Printing Concrete
  11. Liu Zhixin, Li Mingyang, Weng Yiwei, Wong Teck et al. (2018-12)
    Mixture-Design-Approach to Optimize the Rheological Properties of the Material Used in 3D Cementitious Material-Printing
  12. Ma Guowei, Li Zhijian, Wang Li (2017-12)
    Printable Properties of Cementitious Material Containing Copper-Tailings for Extrusion-Based 3D Printing
  13. Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Mohamed Nisar, Tay Yi et al. (2017-09)
    Measurement of Tensile Bond Strength of 3D Printed Geopolymer Mortar
  14. Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Tan Ming (2017-07)
    Anisotropic Mechanical Performance of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Sustainable Construction-Material
  15. Paul Suvash, Tay Yi, Panda Biranchi, Tan Ming (2017-08)
    Fresh and Hardened Properties of 3D Printable Cementitious Materials for Building and Construction
  16. Pegna Joseph (1997-02)
    Exploratory Investigation of Solid Freeform Construction
  17. Sanjayan Jay, Nematollahi Behzad, Xia Ming, Marchment Taylor (2018-04)
    Effect of Surface Moisture on Inter-Layer Strength of 3D Printed Concrete
  18. Soltan Daniel, Li Victor (2018-03)
    A Self-Reinforced Cementitious Composite for Building-Scale 3D Printing
  19. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2018-02)
    Early-Age Mechanical Behaviour of 3D Printed Concrete:
    Numerical Modelling and Experimental Testing
  20. Zareiyan Babak, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2017-08)
    Effects of Interlocking on Inter-Layer Adhesion and Strength of Structures in 3D Printing of Concrete

90 Citations

  1. Sunny Akash, Jayaprakash Jaganathan (2025-12)
    Unveiling the Printing Success of Concrete 3D Printed Models:
    A Simulation Study with Voxel Print and Abaqus Using Design of Experiments
  2. Hasan Md, Xu Jie, Uddin Md (2025-11)
    A Critical Review of 3D Printed Fiber-Based Geopolymer Concrete:
    Fresh Properties, Mechanical Performance, and Current Limitations
  3. Adeel Muhammad (2025-11)
    Three-Dimensional Concrete Printing for Sustainable Construction and Architecture:
    A Comprehensive Review
  4. Ke Zhijiang, Li Zichang, Chen Zhengfei, Xu Yao et al. (2025-10)
    Technological Advancements and Challenges of Robotic Arm-Based 3D Printing for Hydraulic Tunnel Lining
  5. Wang Yufei, Sun Junbo, Wang Xiangyu, Huang Bo et al. (2025-09)
    Environmental and Economic Evaluation of a Prefabricated 3D-Printed Structural Units Using Recycled Aggregates from Construction and Demolition Waste:
    A Case Study in China
  6. Murtaza Ghulam, Baldinelli Giorgio (2025-08)
    Revolutionizing Architecture:
    3D Printing in Large Construction Industry and Strategic Innovations for Enhanced Performance
  7. Yang Xia, Wang Jiuyuan, Huang Han, Wu Gengchen et al. (2025-08)
    Anti-Washout Cement-Based Material for Under-Seawater 3D Concrete Printing:
    Design, Mechanical Properties and Microstructural Analysis
  8. Gerges Isabelle, Farraj Faten, Youssef Nicolas, Antczak Emmanuel et al. (2025-07)
    Methodologies to Design Optimum 3D Printable Mortar Mix:
    A Review
  9. Pei Qiang, Zhong Yingzhu, Wang Shuai, Zhang Luxi et al. (2025-06)
    Interlayer Bonding Shear Performance and Constitutive Model of 3DPC with Different Fine Aggregate Gradations
  10. Mohamed Osama, Mishra Anamika, Isam Fida (2025-05)
    An Overview of 3D Printed Concrete for Building Structures:
    Material Properties, Sustainability, Future Opportunities, and Challenges
  11. Mishra Sanjeet, Snehal K., Das B., Chandrasekaran Rajasekaran et al. (2025-05)
    From Printing to Performance:
    A Review on 3D Concrete Printing Processes, Materials, and Life Cycle Assessment
  12. Maralapalle Vedprakash, Kumavat Hemraj, Nadaf Maheboobsab, Zende Aijaz et al. (2025-04)
    Optimizing 3D Geopolymer Concrete for Sustainable Construction:
    A Review of Material Selection, Printing Methods, and Properties
  13. Yuan Yong, Sheng Ruyi, Yao Xupeng, Pichler Bernhard et al. (2025-03)
    A Three-Step Development Strategy for 3D Printable Concrete Containing Coarse Aggregates
  14. Park Ji-seul, Jeong Seung-Su, Hong Seungkee, Lee Seohyung et al. (2025-02)
    Mechanical Modeling for Prediction of Structural Stability of Cylindrical Structures During 3D Concrete Printing
  15. Chen Meng, Yu Kanghao, Zhang Tong, Wang Yuting (2025-01)
    Characterizing and Modelling the Bond-Slip-Behavior of Steel-Bars in 3D Printed Engineered Cementitious Composites
  16. Nadi Mouad, Majdoubi Hicham, Haddaji Younesse, Bili Oumaima et al. (2025-01)
    Digital Fabrication Processes for Cementitious Materials Using Three-Dimensional 3D Printing Technologies
  17. Zhi Zhenzhen, Guo Yanfei, Qi Huahui, Tan Hongbo et al. (2024-11)
    Effect of Alkali-Metal-Sulfates on Hydration Properties of Alpha-Calcium-Sulfate-Hemihydrate for 3D Printing
  18. Zhao Herui, Jiang Quan, Xia Yong, Liu Jian et al. (2024-11)
    Microbial-Induced Carbonate Reinforcement for 3D Printed Concrete:
    Testing in Printable and Mechanical Strength
  19. Chen Yidong, Zhang Yunsheng, Quan Hongzhu, Liu Cheng et al. (2024-10)
    Early-Age Time-Dependent Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Concrete with Coarse Aggregates
  20. Chamatete Kunda, Yalçınkaya Çağlar (2024-10)
    Numerical Assessment of Thermal Bridging Effects in 3D Printed Foam-Concrete Walls
  21. Aghaee Kamran, Li Linfei, Roshan Alireza, Namakiaraghi Parsa (2024-08)
    Additive Manufacturing Evolution in Construction:
    From Individual Terrestrial to Collective, Aerial, and Extraterrestrial Applications
  22. Yuan Shuaihua, Duan Dengke, Sun Junbo, Yu Yi et al. (2024-08)
    Mechanical, Alkali Excitation, Hydrothermal Enhancement of 3D Printed Concrete Incorporated with Antimony-Tailings
  23. Khan Mehran, McNally Ciaran (2024-05)
    Recent Developments on Low-Carbon 3D Printing Concrete:
    Revolutionizing Construction Through Innovative Technology
  24. An Dong, Zhang Yixia, Yang Chunhui (2024-05)
    Incorporating Coarse Aggregates into 3D Concrete Printing from Mixture Design and Process-Control to Structural Behavior and Practical Applications:
    A Review
  25. Hassan Habibelrahman, Rodriguez-Ubinas Edwin, Tamimi Adil, Trepci Esra et al. (2024-04)
    Towards Innovative and Sustainable Buildings:
    A Comprehensive Review of 3D Printing in Construction
  26. Chamatete Kunda, Yalçınkaya Çağlar (2024-03)
    Numerical Evaluation on Thermal Performance of 3D Printed Concrete Walls:
    The Effects of Lattice-Type, Filament-Width and Granular-Filling-Material
  27. Wang Xiaonan, Li Wengui, Guo Yipu, Kashani Alireza et al. (2024-02)
    Concrete 3D Printing Technology in Sustainable Construction:
    A Review on Raw Materials, Concrete Types and Performances
  28. Silva Guido, Quispe Axcel, Baldoceda Jordan, Kim Suyeon et al. (2024-02)
    Additive Construction of Concrete Deep Beams Using Low-Cost Characterization Methods and FEM-Based Topological Optimization
  29. Kakarla Akesh, Kong Ing, Patel Vipulkumar (2024-02)
    Additive Manufacturing for Building and Constructions
  30. Liu Xiongfei, Cai Huachong, Ma Guowei, Hou Guanyu (2024-01)
    Spray-Based 3D Concrete Printing-Parameter Design-Model:
    Actionable Insight for High Printing Quality
  31. Özalp Fatih (2024-01)
    Mechanical Behavior and Permeability Properties of Sustainable and High-Performance Anisotropic Three-Dimensional Printable Concrete
  32. Liu Huawei, Liu Chao, Zhang Yamei, Bai Guoliang (2023-11)
    Bonding Properties Between 3D Printed Coarse Aggregate Concrete and Rebar Based on Interface Structural Characteristics
  33. Zhou Yi, Althoey Fadi, Alotaibi Badr, Gamil Yaser et al. (2023-10)
    An Overview of Recent Advancements in Fiber-Reinforced 3D Printing Concrete
  34. Genc Gokhan, Demircan Ruya, Beyhan Figen, Kaplan Gökhan (2023-10)
    Assessment of the Sustainability and Producibility of Adobe-Constructions Reinforced with Ca-Based Binders:
    Environmental Life-Cycle-Analysis and 3D Printability
  35. Liu Dawei, Zhang Zhigang, Zhang Xiaoyue, Chen Zhaohui (2023-09)
    3D Printing Concrete Structures:
    State of the Art, Challenges, and Opportunities
  36. Chen Yidong, Zhang Yunsheng, Zhang Yu, Pang Bo et al. (2023-08)
    Influence of Gradation on Extrusion-Based 3D Printing Concrete with Coarse Aggregate
  37. Surehali Sahil, Tripathi Avinaya, Neithalath Narayanan (2023-08)
    Anisotropy in Additively Manufactured Concrete Specimens Under Compressive Loading:
    Quantification of the Effects of Layer-Height and Fiber-Reinforcement
  38. Zhang Yu, Yang Lin, Qian Rusheng, Liu Guojian et al. (2023-07)
    Inter-Layer Adhesion of 3D Printed Concrete:
    Influence of Layer Stacked Vertically
  39. Tu Haidong, Wei Zhenyun, Bahrami Alireza, Kahla Nabil et al. (2023-06)
    Recent Advancements and Future Trends in 3D Printing Concrete Using Waste-Materials
  40. Hou Shaodan, Duan Zhenhua, Ye Taohua, Zou Shuai et al. (2023-06)
    Mechanical Properties and Pore-Structure of 3D Printed Mortar with Recycled Powder
  41. Heywood Kate, Nicholas Paul (2023-06)
    Sustainability and 3D Concrete Printing:
    Identifying a Need for a More Holistic Approach to Assessing Environmental Impacts
  42. Wu Yiwen, Liu Chao, Bai Guoliang, Liu Huawei et al. (2023-03)
    3D Printed Concrete with Recycled Sand:
    Pore-Structure and Triaxial Compression Properties
  43. Chen Hao, Zhang Daobo, Chen Peng, Li Ning et al. (2023-03)
    A Review of the Extruder System Design for Large-Scale Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing
  44. Chen Yidong, Zhang Wenhua, Zhang Yunsheng, Zhang Yu et al. (2023-03)
    3D Printed Concrete with Coarse Aggregates:
    Built-In-Stirrup Permanent Concrete Formwork for Reinforced Columns
  45. Nair Avinash, Aditya S., Adarsh R., Nandan M. et al. (2023-03)
    Additive Manufacturing of Concrete:
    Challenges and Opportunities
  46. Waqar Ahsan, Othman Idris, Pomares Juan (2023-02)
    Impact of 3D Printing on the Overall Project Success of Residential Construction Projects Using Structural Equation Modelling
  47. Xiao Jianzhuang, Hou Shaodan, Duan Zhenhua, Zou Shuai (2023-01)
    Rheology of 3D Printable Concrete Prepared by Secondary Mixing of Ready-Mix Concrete
  48. Poudelet Louison, Molina Miguel, Calvo Laura, Cardona Roger et al. (2023-01)
    Comparison Between Mono- and Bi-Component Extruders in Concrete Additive Manufacturing
  49. Ahmed Ghafur (2023-01)
    A Review of 3D Concrete Printing:
    Materials and Process Characterization, Economic Considerations and Environmental Sustainability
  50. Surehali Sahil, Tripathi Avinaya, Nimbalkar Atharwa, Neithalath Narayanan (2023-01)
    Anisotropic Chloride Transport in 3D Printed Concrete and Its Dependence on Layer-Height and Interface-Types
  51. Raphael Benny, Senthilnathan Shanmugaraj, Patel Abhishek, Bhat Saqib (2023-01)
    A Review of Concrete 3D Printed Structural Members
  52. Yang Jun-Mo, Park In-Beom, Lee Hojae, Kwon Hongkyu (2022-12)
    Effects of Nozzle Details on Print Quality and Hardened Properties of Underwater 3D Printed Concrete
  53. Puzatova (nee Sharanova) Anastasiia, Shakor Pshtiwan, Laghi Vittoria, Dmitrieva Maria (2022-11)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing for Construction Application by Means of Robotic Arm and Gantry 3D Printer:
    A Review
  54. Qaidi Shaker, Yahia Ammar, Tayeh B., Unis H. et al. (2022-10)
    3D Printed Geopolymer Composites:
    A Review
  55. Kaliyavaradhan Senthil, Ambily Parukutty, Prem Prabhat, Ghodke Swapnil (2022-08)
    Test-Methods for 3D Printable Concrete
  56. Inaty Francois, Baz Bilal, Aouad Georges (2022-07)
    Long-Term Durability-Assessment of 3D Printed Concrete
  57. Yu Shiwei, Sanjayan Jay, Du Hongjian (2022-07)
    Effects of Cement Mortar Characteristics on Aggregate-Bed 3D Concrete Printing
  58. Ahmed Ghafur, Askandar Nasih, Jumaa Ghazi (2022-07)
    A Review of Large-Scale 3DCP:
    Material-Characteristics, Mix-Design, Printing-Process, and Reinforcement-Strategies
  59. Wang Xianggang, Jia Lutao, Jia Zijian, Zhang Chao et al. (2022-06)
    Optimization of 3D Printing Concrete with Coarse Aggregate via Proper Mix-Design and Printing-Process
  60. Zhang Chao, Jia Zijian, Wang Xianggang, Jia Lutao et al. (2022-05)
    A Two-Phase Design-Strategy Based on the Composite of Mortar and Coarse Aggregate for 3D Printable Concrete with Coarse Aggregate
  61. Yang Rijiao, Zeng Qiang, Peng Yu, Wang Hailong et al. (2022-05)
    Anomalous Matrix and Inter-Layer Pore-Structure of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Cementitious Composites
  62. Liu Huawei, Liu Chao, Bai Guoliang, Wu Yiwen et al. (2022-04)
    Influence of Pore-Defects on the Hardened Properties of 3D Printed Concrete with Coarse Aggregate
  63. Chen Yidong, Zhang Yunsheng, Pang Bo, Wang Dafu et al. (2022-04)
    Steel-Fiber Orientational Distribution and Effects on 3D Printed Concrete with Coarse Aggregate
  64. Mo Yixin, Xing Jianchun, Yue Songlin, Zhang Yamei et al. (2022-04)
    Dynamic Properties of 3D Printed Cement Mortar Based on Split Hopkinson Pressure Bar Testing
  65. Xiao Jianzhuang, Lv Zhenyuan, Duan Zhenhua, Hou Shaodan (2022-03)
    Study on Preparation and Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Concrete with Different Aggregate-Combinations
  66. Guamán-Rivera Robert, Martínez-Rocamora Alejandro, García-Alvarado Rodrigo, Muñoz-Sanguinetti Claudia et al. (2022-02)
    Recent Developments and Challenges of 3D Printed Construction:
    A Review of Research Fronts
  67. Ji Guangchao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Zhi Peng, Wu Yuching et al. (2022-02)
    Effects of Extrusion-Parameters on Properties of 3D Printing Concrete with Coarse Aggregates
  68. Amran Mugahed, Abdelgader Hakim, Onaizi Ali, Fediuk Roman et al. (2021-12)
    3D Printable Alkali-Activated Concretes for Building Applications:
    A Critical Review
  69. Yuan Philip, Zhan Qiang, Wu Hao, Beh Hooi et al. (2021-11)
    Real-Time Tool-Path-Planning and Extrusion-Control-Method for Variable-Width 3D Concrete Printing
  70. Hou Shaodan, Xiao Jianzhuang, Duan Zhenhua, Ma Guowei (2021-10)
    Fresh Properties of 3D Printed Mortar with Recycled Powder
  71. Mo Yixin, Yue Songlin, Zhou Qizhen, Feng Bowei et al. (2021-09)
    Dynamic Properties and Fractal Characteristics of 3D Printed Cement Mortar in SHPB-Test
  72. Liu Chenkang, Yue Songlin, Zhou Cong, Sun Honglei et al. (2021-08)
    Anisotropic Mechanical Properties of Extrusion-Based 3D Printed Layered Concrete
  73. Yu Shiwei, Xia Ming, Sanjayan Jay, Yang Lin et al. (2021-07)
    Microstructural Characterization of 3D Printed Concrete
  74. Nair Sooraj, Panda Subhashree, Tripathi Avinaya, Neithalath Narayanan (2021-06)
    Relating Print-Velocity and Extrusion-Characteristics of 3D Printable Cementitious Binders:
    Implications Towards Testing Methods
  75. Xiao Jianzhuang, Ji Guangchao, Zhang Yamei, Ma Guowei et al. (2021-06)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing Concrete Technology:
    Current Status and Future Opportunities
  76. Chen Yidong, Zhang Yunsheng, Pang Bo, Liu Zhiyong et al. (2021-05)
    Extrusion-Based 3D Printing Concrete with Coarse Aggregate:
    Printability and Direction-Dependent Mechanical Performance
  77. Schuldt Steven, Jagoda Jeneé, Hoisington Andrew, Delorit Justin (2021-03)
    A Systematic Review and Analysis of the Viability of 3D Printed Construction in Remote Environments
  78. Hou Shaodan, Duan Zhenhua, Xiao Jianzhuang, Ye Jun (2020-12)
    A Review of 3D Printed Concrete:
    Performance-Requirements, Testing Measurements and Mix-Design
  79. Xiao Jianzhuang, Liu Haoran, Ding Tao (2020-11)
    Finite-Element-Analysis on the Anisotropic Behavior of 3D Printed Concrete under Compression and Flexure
  80. Vespalec Arnošt, Novák Josef, Kohoutková Alena, Vosynek Petr et al. (2020-11)
    Interface Behavior and Interface Tensile Strength of a Hardened Concrete Mixture with a Coarse Aggregate for Additive Manufacturing
  81. Souza Marcelo, Ferreira Igor, Moraes Elisângela, Senff Luciano et al. (2020-09)
    3D Printed Concrete for Large-Scale Buildings:
    An Overview of Rheology, Printing Parameters, Chemical Admixtures, Reinforcements, and Economic and Environmental Prospects
  82. Han Yilong, Yang Zhihan, Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang (2020-08)
    Environmental and Economic Assessment on 3D Printed Buildings with Recycled Concrete
  83. Yu Shiwei, Du Hongjian, Sanjayan Jay (2020-07)
    Aggregate-Bed 3D Concrete Printing with Cement-Paste Binder
  84. Wang Yu, Li Shuaishuai, Qin Tian, Yu Ying et al. (2020-07)
    Concrete 3D Printing:
    System Development, Process Planning and Experimental Results
  85. Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Zou Shuai, Wang Yu (2020-06)
    Hardened Properties of Layered 3D Printed Concrete with Recycled Sand
  86. Moeini Mohammad, Hosseinpoor Masoud, Yahia Ammar (2020-05)
    Effectiveness of the Rheometric Methods to Evaluate the Build-Up of Cementitious Mortars Used for 3D Printing
  87. Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Qin Fei, Duan Zhenhua (2020-03)
    Mechanical Behavior of 3D Printed Mortar with Recycled Sand at Early-Ages
  88. Khalil Abdullah, Wang Xiangyu, Celik Kemal (2020-02)
    3D Printable Magnesium Oxide Concrete:
    Towards Sustainable Modern Architecture
  89. Li Zhijian, Wang Li, Ma Guowei (2020-01)
    Mechanical Improvement of Continuous Steel-Micro-Cable-Reinforced Geopolymer Composites for 3D Printing Subjected to Different Loading Conditions
  90. Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh, Will Frank, Näther Mathias et al. (2019-08)
    Large-Scale Digital Concrete Construction:
    CONPrint3D Concept for On-Site, Monolithic 3D Printing

BibTeX
@article{ji_ding_xiao_du.2019.A3PRMCPDS,
  author            = "Guangchao Ji and Tao Ding and Jianzhuang Xiao and Shupeng Du and Jun Li and Zhenhua Duan",
  title             = "A 3D Printed Ready-Mixed Concrete Power-Distribution Substation: Materials and Construction Technology",
  doi               = "10.3390/ma12091540",
  year              = "2019",
  journal           = "Materials",
  volume            = "12",
  number            = "9",
}
Formatted Citation

G. Ji, T. Ding, J. Xiao, S. Du, J. Li and Z. Duan, “A 3D Printed Ready-Mixed Concrete Power-Distribution Substation: Materials and Construction Technology”, Materials, vol. 12, no. 9, 2019, doi: 10.3390/ma12091540.

Ji, Guangchao, Tao Ding, Jianzhuang Xiao, Shupeng Du, Jun Li, and Zhenhua Duan. “A 3D Printed Ready-Mixed Concrete Power-Distribution Substation: Materials and Construction Technology”. Materials 12, no. 9 (2019). https://doi.org/10.3390/ma12091540.