Explainable Data-Driven Modeling for Optimized Mix Design of 3D-Printed Concrete (2025-11)¶
Abbas Yassir, Alsaif Abdulaziz
Journal Article - Computer Modeling in Engineering & Sciences, Vol. 145, Iss. 2, pp. 1789-1819
Abstract
The rapid advancement of three-dimensional printed concrete (3DPC) requires intelligent and interpretable frameworks to optimize mixture design for strength, printability, and sustainability. While machine learning (ML) models have improved predictive accuracy, their limited transparency has hindered their widespread adoption in materials engineering. To overcome this barrier, this study introduces a Random Forests ensemble learning model integrated with SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) and Partial Dependence Plots (PDPs) to model and explain the compressive strength behavior of 3DPC mixtures. Unlike conventional “black-box” models, SHAP quantifies each variable’s contribution to predictions based on cooperative game theory, which enables causal interpretability, whereas PDP visualizes nonlinear and interactive effects between features that offer practical mix design insights. A systematically optimized random forest model achieved strong generalization (R2 = 0.978 for training, 0.834 for validation, and 0.868 for testing). The analysis identified curing age, Portland cement, silica fume, and the water-tobinder ratio as dominant predictors, with curing age exerting the highest positive influence on strength development. The integrated SHAP-PDP framework revealed synergistic interactions among binder constituents and curing parameters, which established transparent, data-driven guidelines for performance optimization. Theoretically, the study advances explainable artificial intelligence in cementitious material science by linking microstructural mechanisms to model-based reasoning, thereby enhancing both the interpretability and applicability ofML-driven mix design for next-generation 3DPC systems.
¶
94 References
- Álvarez-Fernández Martina, Prendes-Gero María, González-Nicieza Celestino, Guerrero-Miguel Diego-José et al. (2021-02)
Optimum Mix-Design for 3D Concrete Printing Using Mining-Tailings:
A Case Study in Spain - Alyami Mana, Khan Majid, Fawad Muhammad, Nawahz R. et al. (2023-11)
Predictive Modeling for Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete Using Machine Learning Algorithms - Arif Muhammad, Jan Faizullah, Rezzoug Aïssa, Afridi Muhammad et al. (2024-11)
Data-Driven Models for Predicting Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete Using Interpretable Machine Learning Algorithms - Assaad Joseph, Hamzeh Farook, Hamad Bilal (2020-05)
Qualitative Assessment of Interfacial Bonding in 3D Printing Concrete Exposed to Frost-Attack - Baz Bilal, Aouad Georges, Khalil Noura, Rémond Sébastien (2020-11)
Inter-Layer Reinforcement of 3D Printed Concrete Elements - Baz Bilal, Aouad Georges, Rémond Sébastien (2020-01)
Effect of the Printing Method and Mortar’s Workability on Pull-Out Strength of 3D Printed Elements - Bhattacherjee Shantanu, Jain Smrati, Santhanam Manu (2022-11)
Criticality of Binder-Aggregate Interaction for Buildability of 3D Printed Concrete Containing Limestone-Calcined-Clay - Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2016-08)
Additive Manufacturing of Concrete in Construction:
Potentials and Challenges of 3D Concrete Printing - Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Jones Scott, Dirrenberger Justin (2018-06)
3D Printing Using Concrete-Extrusion:
A Roadmap for Research - Chen Yu, Li Zhenming, Figueiredo Stefan, Çopuroğlu Oğuzhan et al. (2019-04)
Limestone and Calcined-Clay-Based Sustainable Cementitious Materials for 3D Concrete Printing:
A Fundamental Study of Extrudability and Early-Age Strength Development - Cho Seung, Kruger Jacques, Rooyen Algurnon, Zeranka Stephan et al. (2019-09)
Rheology of 3D Printable Lightweight Foam-Concrete Incorporating Nano-Silica - Chourasia Ajay, Pal Biswajit, Kapoor Ashish (2025-02)
Influence of Printing Direction and Interlayer Printing Time on the Bond Characteristics and Hardened Mechanical Properties of Agro-Industrial Waste-Based 3D Printed Concrete - Colyn Markus, Zijl Gideon, Babafemi Adewumi (2024-02)
Fresh and Strength Properties of 3D Printable Concrete Mixtures Utilising a High Volume of Sustainable Alternative Binders - Cui Weijiu, Shen Liang, Ji Dongsheng, Liu Wenliang et al. (2024-07)
Mechanical Performance and Permeability of Low-Carbon Printable Concrete - Cui Weijiu, Wang Tianheng, Chen Xu, Shen Wenkai et al. (2023-03)
Study of 3D Printed Concrete with Low-Carbon Cementitious Materials Based on Its Rheological Properties and Mechanical Performances - Cui Hongzhi, Yu Shiheng, Cao Xiangpeng, Yang Haibin (2022-03)
Evaluation of Printability and Thermal Properties of 3D Printed Concrete Mixed with Phase-Change-Materials - Ding Tao, Qin Fei, Xiao Jianzhuang, Chen Xiaoming et al. (2022-01)
Experimental Study on the Bond Behavior Between Steel-Bars and 3D Printed Concrete - Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Qin Fei, Duan Zhenhua (2020-03)
Mechanical Behavior of 3D Printed Mortar with Recycled Sand at Early-Ages - Ding Tao, Xiao Jianzhuang, Zou Shuai, Wang Yu (2020-06)
Hardened Properties of Layered 3D Printed Concrete with Recycled Sand - Federowicz Karol, Kaszyńska Maria, Zieliński Adam, Hoffmann Marcin (2020-06)
Effect of Curing Methods on Shrinkage Development in 3D Printed Concrete - Ghasemi Alireza, Naser Mohannad (2023-07)
Tailoring 3D Printed Concrete Through Explainable Artificial Intelligence - Hack Norman, Mai (née Dressler) Inka, Brohmann Leon, Gantner Stefan et al. (2020-03)
Injection 3D Concrete Printing (I3DCP):
Basic Principles and Case Studies - Hambach Manuel, Volkmer Dirk (2017-02)
Properties of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Portland-Cement-Paste - Hassan Habibelrahman, Rodriguez-Ubinas Edwin, Tamimi Adil, Trepci Esra et al. (2024-04)
Towards Innovative and Sustainable Buildings:
A Comprehensive Review of 3D Printing in Construction - Heever Marchant, Bester Frederick, Kruger Jacques, Zijl Gideon (2021-07)
Mechanical Characterisation for Numerical Simulation of Extrusion-Based 3D Concrete Printing - Huseien Ghasan, Tan Shea, Saleh Ali, Lim Nor et al. (2024-08)
Test-Procedures and Mechanical Properties of Three-Dimensional Printable Concrete Enclosing Different Mix-Proportions:
A Review and Bibliometric Analysis - Izadgoshasb Hamed, Kandiri Amirreza, Shakor Pshtiwan, Laghi Vittoria et al. (2021-11)
Predicting Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Mortar in Structural Members Using Machine Learning - Jiang Xiongzhi, Li Yujia, Yang Zhe, Li Yangbo et al. (2024-02)
Harnessing Path-Optimization to Enhance the Strength of Three-Dimensional Printed Concrete - Jo Jun, Jo Byung, Cho Woohyun, Kim Jung-Hoon (2020-03)
Development of a 3D Printer for Concrete Structures:
Laboratory Testing of Cementitious Materials - Joh Changbin, Lee Jungwoo, Bui The, Park Jihun et al. (2020-11)
Buildability and Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Concrete - Kaszyńska Maria, Skibicki Szymon, Hoffmann Marcin (2020-12)
3D Concrete Printing for Sustainable Construction - Kazemian Ali, Yuan Xiao, Cochran Evan, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2017-04)
Cementitious Materials for Construction-Scale 3D Printing:
Laboratory Testing of Fresh Printing Mixture - Khalil Noura, Aouad Georges, Cheikh Khadija, Rémond Sébastien (2017-09)
Use of Calcium-Sulfoaluminate-Cements for Setting-Control of 3D Printing Mortars - Kloft Harald, Krauss Hans-Werner, Hack Norman, Herrmann Eric et al. (2020-05)
Influence of Process Parameters on the Inter-Layer Bond Strength of Concrete Elements Additive Manufactured by Shotcrete 3D Printing - Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
Mix-Design and Fresh Properties for High-Performance Printing Concrete - Li L., Fang Z., Chu S., Kwan Albert (2024-11)
Improving Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Mortar by Exploiting Synergistic Effects of Fly-Ash-Microsphere and Nano-Silica - Liu Chao, Wang Xianggang, Chen Yuning, Zhang Chao et al. (2021-06)
Influence of Hydroxypropyl-Methylcellulose and Silica-Fume on Stability, Rheological Properties, and Printability of 3D Printing Foam-Concrete - Liu Chao, Zhang Rongfei, Liu Huawei, He Chunhui et al. (2021-11)
Analysis of the Mechanical Performance and Damage Mechanism for 3D Printed Concrete Based on Pore-Structure - Long Wujian, Tao Jie-Lin, Lin Can, Gu Yucun et al. (2019-08)
Rheology and Buildability of Sustainable Cement-Based Composites Containing Micro-Crystalline Cellulose for 3D Printing - Ma Lei, Zhang Qing, Jia Zijian, Liu Chao et al. (2021-11)
Effect of Drying Environment on Mechanical Properties, Internal RH and Pore-Structure of 3D Printed Concrete - Mai (née Dressler) Inka, Freund Niklas, Lowke Dirk (2020-01)
The Effect of Accelerator Dosage on Fresh Concrete Properties and on Inter-Layer Strength in Shotcrete 3D Printing - Malik Umair, Riaz Raja, Rehman Saif, Usman Muhammad et al. (2024-07)
Advancing Mix-Design Prediction in 3D Printed Concrete:
Predicting Anisotropic Compressive Strength and Slump-Flow - Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh, Will Frank, Näther Mathias et al. (2019-08)
Large-Scale Digital Concrete Construction:
CONPrint3D Concept for On-Site, Monolithic 3D Printing - Meurer Maximilian, Claßen Martin (2021-02)
Mechanical Properties of Hardened 3D Printed Concretes and Mortars:
Development of a Consistent Experimental Characterization-Strategy - Mütevelli Özkan İffet, Aldemir Alper (2024-07)
Machine-Learning Networks to Predict the Ultimate Axial Load and Displacement Capacity of 3D Printed Concrete Walls with Different Section Geometries - Nerella Venkatesh, Hempel Simone, Mechtcherine Viktor (2019-02)
Effects of Layer-Interface Properties on Mechanical Performance of Concrete Elements Produced by Extrusion-Based 3D Printing - Nerella Venkatesh, Mechtcherine Viktor (2019-02)
Studying the Printability of Fresh Concrete for Formwork-Free Concrete Onsite 3D Printing Technology (CONPrint3D) - Overmeir Anne, Figueiredo Stefan, Šavija Branko, Bos Freek et al. (2022-02)
Design and Analyses of Printable Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites with Optimized Particle-Size-Distribution - Overmeir Anne, Šavija Branko, Bos Freek, Schlangen Erik (2023-08)
3D Printable Strain-Hardening Cementitious Composites (3DP-SHCC):
Tailoring Fresh and Hardened State Properties - Pan Zuanfeng, Si Doudou, Tao Jinghong, Xiao Jianzhuang (2023-02)
Compressive Behavior of 3D Printed Concrete with Different Printing Paths and Concrete Ages - Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Mohamed Nisar, Tay Yi et al. (2017-09)
Measurement of Tensile Bond Strength of 3D Printed Geopolymer Mortar - Panda Biranchi, Ruan Shaoqin, Unluer Cise, Tan Ming (2018-11)
Improving the 3D Printability of High-Volume Fly-Ash Mixtures via the Use of Nano-Attapulgite-Clay - Perrot Arnaud, Jacquet Yohan, Caron Jean-François, Mesnil Romain et al. (2024-08)
Snapshot on 3D Printing with Alternative Binders and Materials:
Earth, Geopolymers, Gypsum and Low-Carbon Concrete - Perrot Arnaud, Pierre Alexandre, Nerella Venkatesh, Wolfs Robert et al. (2021-07)
From Analytical Methods to Numerical Simulations:
A Process Engineering Toolbox for 3D Concrete Printing - Pham Luong, Lu Guoxing, Tran Jonathan (2022-02)
Influences of Printing-Pattern on Mechanical Performance of Three-Dimensional-Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete - Pierre Alexandre, Weger Daniel, Perrot Arnaud, Lowke Dirk (2018-01)
Penetration of Cement-Pastes into Sand-Packings During 3D Printing:
Analytical and Experimental Study - Putten Jolien, Snoeck Didier, Coensel R., Schutter Geert et al. (2020-12)
Early-Age Shrinkage Phenomena of 3D Printed Cementitious Materials with Superabsorbent Polymers - Rahul Attupurathu, Mohan Manu, Schutter Geert, Tittelboom Kim (2021-10)
3D Printable Concrete with Natural and Recycled Coarse Aggregates:
Rheological, Mechanical and Shrinkage Behavior - Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu (2020-02)
Evaluating the Printability of Concretes Containing Lightweight Coarse Aggregates - Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu, Meena Hitesh, Ghani Zimam (2018-12)
3D Printable Concrete:
Mixture-Design and Test-Methods - Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu, Meena Hitesh, Ghani Zimam (2019-08)
Mechanical Characterization of 3D Printable Concrete - Rasel Risul, Hossain Md, Zubayer Md, Zhang Chaoqun (2024-11)
Exploring the Fresh and Rheology Properties of 3D Printed Concrete with Fiber-Reinforced Composites:
A Novel Approach Using Machine Learning Techniques - Rehman Saif, Riaz Raja, Usman Muhammad, Kim In-Ho (2024-08)
Augmented Data-Driven Approach Towards 3D Printed Concrete Mix Prediction - Rushing Todd, Chaar Ghassan, Eick Brian, Burroughs Jedadiah et al. (2017-01)
Investigation of Concrete Mixtures for Additive Construction - Şahin Hatice, Mardani Ali (2021-12)
Assessment of Materials, Design Parameters and Some Properties of 3D Printing Concrete Mixtures:
A State of the Art Review - Şahin Hatice, Mardani Ali, Beytekin Hatice (2024-02)
Effect of Silica-Fume Utilization on Structural Build-Up, Mechanical and Dimensional Stability Performance of Fiber-Reinforced 3D Printable Concrete - Schutter Geert, Lesage Karel, Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh et al. (2018-08)
Vision of 3D Printing with Concrete:
Technical, Economic and Environmental Potentials - Shakor Pshtiwan, Nejadi Shami, Paul Gavin (2019-05)
A Study into the Effect of Different Nozzles Shapes and Fiber-Reinforcement in 3D Printed Mortar - Shakor Pshtiwan, Nejadi Shami, Sutjipto Sheila, Paul Gavin et al. (2020-01)
Effects of Deposition-Velocity in the Presence-Absence of E6-Glass-Fiber on Extrusion-Based 3D Printed Mortar - Shen Yuhang, Lin Li, Wei Shengjie, Yan Jie et al. (2022-12)
Research on the Preparation and Mechanical Properties of Solidified 3D Printed Concrete Materials - Singh Amardeep, Liu Qiong, Xiao Jianzhuang, Lyu Qifeng (2022-02)
Mechanical and Macrostructural Properties of 3D Printed Concrete Dosed with Steel-Fibers under Different Loading-Direction - Suryanto Benny, Higgins J., Aitken M., Tambusay Asdam et al. (2023-10)
Developments in Portland Cement/GGBS Binders for 3D Printing Applications:
Material-Calibration and Structural Testing - Tao Yaxin, Rahul Attupurathu, Lesage Karel, Tittelboom Kim et al. (2021-11)
Mechanical and Microstructural Properties of 3D Printable Concrete in the Context of the Twin-Pipe Pumping-Strategy - Tarhan Yeşim, Şahin Remzi (2023-10)
The Physicomechanical Behavior and Microstructure of Air-Entrained 3D Printable Concrete - Ting Andrew, Tay Yi, Annapareddy Ashokreddy, Li Mingyang et al. (2018-05)
Effect of Recycled-Glass Gradation in 3D Cementitious Material-Printing - To Quoc, Pham Koa, Lee Gayoon, Shin Myoungsu et al. (2024-06)
Experimental and FEM Evaluation of the Influence of Inter-Layer Bonding Strength in 3D Printed Concrete Members Under Compressive and Flexural Loadings - Uddin Md, Ye Junhong, Deng Boyu, Li Lingzhi et al. (2023-04)
Interpretable Machine Learning for Predicting the Strength of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete - Uddin Md, Ye Junhong, Haque M., Yu Kequan et al. (2024-04)
A Novel Compressive Strength Estimation Approach for 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Concrete:
Integrating Machine Learning and Gene Expression Programming - Vargas Armando, Robayo-Salazar Rafael, Gutiérrez Ruby (2024-12)
Effects of Incorporating Fine Aggregates and Polypropylene-Micro-Fibers on the Cracking-Control of 3D Printed Cementitious Mixtures - Wang Bolin, Zhai Mingang, Yao Xiaofei, Wu Qing et al. (2022-03)
Printable and Mechanical Performance of 3D Printed Concrete Employing Multiple Industrial Wastes - Weng Yiwei, Li Mingyang, Tan Ming, Qian Shunzhi (2018-01)
Design 3D Printing Cementitious Materials via Fuller-Thompson-Theory and Marson-Percy-Model - Weng Yiwei, Lu Bing, Li Mingyang, Liu Zhixin et al. (2018-09)
Empirical Models to Predict Rheological Properties of Fiber-Reinforced Cementitious Composites for 3D Printing - Wu Yun-Chen, Li Mo (2022-09)
Effects of Early-Age Rheology and Printing Time Interval on Late-Age Fracture Characteristics of 3D Printed Concrete - Xiao Jianzhuang, Liu Haoran, Ding Tao (2020-11)
Finite-Element-Analysis on the Anisotropic Behavior of 3D Printed Concrete under Compression and Flexure - Xiao Jianzhuang, Lv Zhenyuan, Duan Zhenhua, Hou Shaodan (2022-03)
Study on Preparation and Mechanical Properties of 3D Printed Concrete with Different Aggregate-Combinations - Yao Xiaofei, Lyu Xin, Sun Junbo, Wang Bolin et al. (2023-03)
AI-Based Performance Prediction for 3D Printed Concrete Considering Anisotropy and Steam-Curing Condition - Ye Junhong, Cui Can, Yu Jiangtao, Yu Kequan et al. (2021-02)
Effect of Polyethylene-Fiber Content on Workability and Mechanical-Anisotropic Properties of 3D Printed Ultra-High-Ductile Concrete - Yu Kequan, McGee Wesley, Ng Tsz, Zhu He et al. (2021-02)
3D Printable Engineered Cementitious Composites:
Fresh and Hardened Properties - Yu Shiwei, Sanjayan Jay, Du Hongjian (2022-07)
Effects of Cement Mortar Characteristics on Aggregate-Bed 3D Concrete Printing - Zaid Osama, Ouni Mohamed (2024-04)
Advancements in 3D Printing of Cementitious Materials:
A Review of Mineral Additives, Properties, and Systematic Developments - Zhang Jingchuan, Wang Jialiang, Dong Sufen, Yu Xun et al. (2019-07)
A Review of the Current Progress and Application of 3D Printed Concrete - Zhu Ronghua, Egbe King-James, Salehi Hadi, Shi Zhongtian et al. (2024-01)
Eco-Friendly 3D Printed Concrete with Fine Aggregate Replacements:
Fabrication, Characterization and Machine Learning Prediction - Zhu Lingli, Yao Jie, Zhao Yu, Ruan Wenqiang et al. (2023-09)
Printability and Early Mechanical Properties of Material-Composition Modified 3D Printing Engineered Cementitious Composites Based on the Response-Surface-Methodology - Zhuang Zicheng, Xu Fengming, Ye Junhong, Hu Nan et al. (2024-06)
A Comprehensive Review of Sustainable Materials and Tool-Path-Optimization in 3D Concrete Printing
0 Citations
BibTeX
@article{abba_alsa.2025.EDDMfOMDo3PC,
author = "Yassir M. Abbas and Abdulaziz Alsaif",
title = "Explainable Data-Driven Modeling for Optimized Mix Design of 3D-Printed Concrete: Interpreting Nonlinear Synergies Among Binder Components and Proportions",
doi = "10.32604/cmes.2025.073088",
year = "2025",
journal = "Computer Modeling in Engineering & Sciences",
volume = "145",
number = "2",
pages = "1789--1819",
}
Formatted Citation
Y. M. Abbas and A. Alsaif, “Explainable Data-Driven Modeling for Optimized Mix Design of 3D-Printed Concrete: Interpreting Nonlinear Synergies Among Binder Components and Proportions”, Computer Modeling in Engineering & Sciences, vol. 145, no. 2, pp. 1789–1819, 2025, doi: 10.32604/cmes.2025.073088.
Abbas, Yassir M., and Abdulaziz Alsaif. “Explainable Data-Driven Modeling for Optimized Mix Design of 3D-Printed Concrete: Interpreting Nonlinear Synergies Among Binder Components and Proportions”. Computer Modeling in Engineering & Sciences 145, no. 2 (2025): 1789–1819. https://doi.org/10.32604/cmes.2025.073088.