Skip to content

Tool-Path -Based Design for 3D Concrete Printing of Carbon-Efficient Architectural Structures (2022-05)

10.1016/j.addma.2022.102872

 Breseghello Luca,  Naboni Roberto
Journal Article - Additive Manufacturing, Vol. 56

Abstract

The paper presents a data-informed toolpath-based design approach for 3D Concrete Printing (3DCP) for the fabrication of architectural horizontal structures in one continuous printing process. 3DCP has inherent advantages resulting from shaping concrete without formwork and from placing material only where functionally required. However, to date, only a few examples and applications of efficient design solutions through 3DCP exist at the construction scale. Building on the advantages of the technique, the presented work introduces a novel approach for reducing the amount of material employed in structural beams through a high-resolution stress-based optimisation of their material layout in the longitudinal section. The paper presents an innovative workflow for the design and fabrication of 3DCP structures which provides design flexibility by implementing a set of geometric optimisation routines tailored to the concrete extrusion process, and which integrates Finite Element (FE) analysis at multiple stages of the development, for the definition of the printing path, the optimisation of the layer design through speed variation, and the informed placement of the reinforcement bars. The workflow was verified through the design, fabrication and testing of three beam designs which progressively integrates the developed methods. The strength-to-weight ratio of the three designs shows the impact of the proposed workflow, which increases the performance to almost three times between a full beam and the lightest tested beam. The potential for material saving through a design workflow tailored for 3DCP opens to more carbon-efficient and environmental production processes and structures.

20 References

  1. Agustí-Juan Isolda, Müller Florian, Hack Norman, Wangler Timothy et al. (2017-04)
    Potential Benefits of Digital Fabrication for Complex Structures:
    Environmental Assessment of a Robotically Fabricated Concrete Wall
  2. Asprone Domenico, Auricchio Ferdinando, Menna Costantino, Mercuri Valentina (2018-03)
    3D Printing of Reinforced Concrete Elements:
    Technology and Design Approach
  3. Asprone Domenico, Menna Costantino, Bos Freek, Salet Theo et al. (2018-06)
    Rethinking Reinforcement for Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  4. Bhooshan Shajay, Mele Tom, Block Philippe (2020-11)
    Morph & Slerp:
    Shape Description for 3D Printing of Concrete
  5. Breseghello Luca, Naboni Roberto (2021-07)
    Adaptive Tool-Path:
    Enhanced Design and Process-Control for Robotic 3DCP
  6. Breseghello Luca, Sanin Sandro, Naboni Roberto (2021-04)
    Tool-Path Simulation, Design and Manipulation in Robotic 3D Concrete Printing
  7. Buswell Richard, Bos Freek, Silva Wilson, Hack Norman et al. (2022-01)
    Digital Fabrication with Cement-Based Materials:
    Process Classification and Case Studies
  8. Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Bos Freek, Schipper Roel et al. (2020-05)
    A Process Classification Framework for Defining and Describing Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  9. Gebhard Lukas, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Anton Ana-Maria, Dillenburger Benjamin et al. (2021-04)
    Structural Behavior of 3D Printed Concrete Beams with Various Reinforcement-Strategies
  10. Grasser Georg, Pammer Lorenz, Köll Harald, Werner E. et al. (2020-07)
    Complex Architecture in Printed Concrete:
    The Case of the Innsbruck University 350th Anniversary Pavilion COHESION
  11. Maitenaz Sébastien, Mesnil Romain, Onfroy Paul, Metge Nicolas et al. (2020-07)
    Sustainable Reinforced Concrete Beams:
    Mechanical Optimization and 3D Printed Formwork
  12. Mata-Falcón Jaime, Bischof Patrick, Kaufmann Walter (2018-09)
    Exploiting the Potential of Digital Fabrication for Sustainable and Economic Concrete Structures
  13. Mechtcherine Viktor, Buswell Richard, Kloft Harald, Bos Freek et al. (2021-02)
    Integrating Reinforcement in Digital Fabrication with Concrete:
    A Review and Classification Framework
  14. Mohan Manu, Rahul Attupurathu, Schutter Geert, Tittelboom Kim (2020-10)
    Extrusion-Based Concrete 3D Printing from a Material Perspective:
    A State of the Art Review
  15. Panda Biranchi, Paul Suvash, Tan Ming (2017-07)
    Anisotropic Mechanical Performance of 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Sustainable Construction-Material
  16. Paolini Alexander, Kollmannsberger Stefan, Rank Ernst (2019-10)
    Additive Manufacturing in Construction:
    A Review on Processes, Applications, and Digital Planning Methods
  17. Pham Luong, Tran Jonathan, Sanjayan Jay (2020-04)
    Steel-Fiber-Reinforced 3D Printed Concrete:
    Influence of Fiber Sizes on Mechanical Performance
  18. Salet Theo, Ahmed Zeeshan, Bos Freek, Laagland Hans (2018-05)
    Design of a 3D Printed Concrete Bridge by Testing
  19. Soto Borja, Agustí-Juan Isolda, Hunhevicz Jens, Joss Samuel et al. (2018-05)
    Productivity of Digital Fabrication in Construction:
    Cost and Time-Analysis of a Robotically Built Wall
  20. Vantyghem Gieljan, Corte Wouter, Shakour Emad, Amir Oded (2020-01)
    3D Printing of a Post-Tensioned Concrete Girder Designed by Topology-Optimization

57 Citations

  1. Liao Minmao, Sun Xiao, Chen Zhaohui (2026-01)
    Simultaneous Topology and Path Optimization for 3D Concrete Printing Based on Discrete Frame Structures
  2. Skoury Lior, Asaf Ofer, Sprecher Aaron, Menges Achim et al. (2025-12)
    Data-Informed Digital Twin for Large-Scale 3D Printing in Construction
  3. Dörrie Robin, Megnet Manuel, David Martin, Dröder Klaus et al. (2025-12)
    Integration of Discrete Reinforcement Elements for Shotcrete 3D Printing of Complex Structures
  4. Telichko Victor, Slavcheva Galina, Levchenko Artem (2025-12)
    Experimentally Verified FE Model of Bending Reinforced 3D-Printed Concrete Elements
  5. Kim Tae, Oh Sangwoo, Lee Jinsuk, Choi Seongcheol et al. (2025-10)
    Experimental Data-Driven Framework for Quality Control of 3D-Printed Concrete Permanent Formworks
  6. Xiao Yinan, Vandenberg Aileen, Lowke Dirk, Mai (née Dressler) Inka et al. (2025-08)
    Automated Robotic Assembly Planning of Space Trusses for Injection 3D Concrete Printing
  7. Banda-Pérez Pablo, Georgiou Ioulios, Carrasco Pérez Patricio, Soria Romanella et al. (2025-07)
    Deployment for Additive Construction Through Digital Platforms:
    Gananoque Project as a Case Study
  8. Mahdy Deena, Dara Seni, Abdelrahim Marwa (2025-06)
    Evaluating Structure Stability of Self-Supporting 3D Printed Earth-Based Cantilevers Using Robotic ARM
  9. Cisowski Adam, Kowalik Michał (2025-06)
    The Influence of the Cross-Sectional Geometry on Stress Concentration in 3D Printed Concrete Elements:
    A Preliminary Study
  10. Rojas Jorge, Hasanzadeh Sognad (2025-05)
    An Integrated BIM Planning Workflow for 3D Concrete Printing Projects
  11. Salifu N., Bassuoni Mohamed, Guven Gursans (2025-05)
    Performance Evaluation of Limestone-Blended Cement and Cellulose Nanomaterials in 3D Concrete Printing
  12. Dörrie Robin, Gantner Stefan, Amiri Fatemeh, Lachmayer Lukas et al. (2025-04)
    From Digital to Real:
    Optimised and Functionally Integrated Shotcrete 3D Printing Elements for Multi-Storey Structures
  13. Hua Hao, Liu Yizhuo, Hovestadt Ludger, He Siyuan et al. (2025-04)
    Digital Nervi:
    Performance‐based Design of Lightweight Isostatic Ribbed Slab with 3D Printed Concrete Formwork
  14. Zhang Yuying, Zhu Xiaohong, Li Muduo, Zhang Chao et al. (2025-04)
    3D Printing Technology in Concrete Construction
  15. Xiao Yinan, Hack Norman, Kloft Harald, Lowke Dirk et al. (2025-03)
    Constraint-Based Form-Finding of Space Trusses for Injection 3D Concrete Printing Through Vector-Based Graphic Statics
  16. Chai Hwa, Shiotani Tomoki (2025-03)
    Opening Letter of RILEM TC QPA:
    Quality and Performance Assurance of Additively Manufactured Cementitious Composites by Advanced Non-Invasive Techniques
  17. Li Yuhan, Rian Iasef, Chen Hanmei, Tang Shu (2025-03)
    Application of Fractal Curves for 3D Concrete Printing of Porous Prefab Panels
  18. Li Yuhan, Rian Iasef, Chen Hanmei, Tang Shu (2025-03)
    Application of Fractal Curves for 3D Concrete Printing of Porous Prefab Panels
  19. Zhi Yefan, Chai Hua, Teng Teng, Akbarzadeh Masoud (2025-02)
    Automated Toolpath Design of 3D Concrete Printing Structural Components
  20. Yabanigül Meryem, Özer Derya (2024-12)
    Exploring Architectural Units Through Robotic 3D Concrete Printing of Space-Filling Geometries
  21. Khan Mirza, Ahmed Aayzaz, Ali Tariq, Qureshi Muhammad et al. (2024-12)
    Comprehensive Review of 3D Printed Concrete, Life Cycle Assessment, AI and ML Models:
    Materials, Engineered Properties and Techniques for Additive Manufacturing
  22. Jørgensen Henrik, Hansen Steen, Jespersen Esra, Florenzano Daniele et al. (2024-11)
    Experimental Investigation of Key Structural Parameters for Structural Design of 3D Printed Concrete
  23. He Chenming, Michalatos Panagiotis, Sabin Jenny (2024-11)
    GrowFill:
    Generative Adaptive Infill for Additive Manufacturing
  24. He Yuxiang, Robens-Radermacher Annika, Noda Sakiko, Wolf Christoph et al. (2024-11)
    Automated Workflows for Concrete Additive Manufacturing for Design, Optimization, and Fabrication of Parametrized Elements
  25. Li Shuai, Lan Tian, Nguyen Hung-Xuan, Tran Jonathan (2024-10)
    Frontiers in Construction 3D Printing:
    Self-Monitoring, Multi-Robot, Drone-Assisted Processes
  26. Matos Paulo, Schackow Adilson, Safanelli Nicollas, Zat Tuani (2024-09)
    Developing Binders with Ceramic Waste for 3DCP Mixes
  27. Prihar Arjun, Gupta Shashank, Esmaeeli Hadi, Moini Mohamadreza (2024-08)
    Tough Double-Bouligand Architected Concrete Enabled by Robotic Additive Manufacturing
  28. Gebhard Lukas, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Ammann Rebecca, Pressmair Nadine et al. (2024-08)
    Enhancing Structural Efficiency with Digital Concrete:
    Principles, Opportunities and Case Studies
  29. Aghaee Kamran, Li Linfei, Roshan Alireza, Namakiaraghi Parsa (2024-08)
    Additive Manufacturing Evolution in Construction:
    From Individual Terrestrial to Collective, Aerial, and Extraterrestrial Applications
  30. Zhi Yefan, Teng Teng, Akbarzadeh Masoud (2024-08)
    Designing 3D Printed Concrete Structures with Scaled Fabrication Models
  31. Raza Muhammad, Besklubova Svetlana, Zhong Ray (2024-07)
    Economic Analysis of Offsite and Onsite 3D Construction Printing Techniques for Low-Story Buildings:
    A Comparative Value-Stream-Assessment
  32. Duarte Gonçalo, Brown Nathan, Duarte José (2024-07)
    Workflow for Generating, Simulating, and Optimizing Form and Tool-Path in 3D Concrete Printing of Vaults
  33. Zhuang Zicheng, Xu Fengming, Ye Junhong, Hu Nan et al. (2024-06)
    A Comprehensive Review of Sustainable Materials and Tool-Path-Optimization in 3D Concrete Printing
  34. Matos Paulo, Prigol Hellen, Schackow Adilson, Silva Nazário Samara et al. (2024-06)
    Quality-Control-Tests of Fresh 3D Printable Cement-Based Materials
  35. Wu Chengde, Evans Pete (2024-05)
    An Integrated System for Improving 3D Concrete Printing Process
  36. García-Alvarado Rodrigo, Soza-Ruiz Pedro, Moroni-Orellana Ginnia, Pedreros Fernando et al. (2024-05)
    From BIM-Model to 3D Construction Printing:
    A Framework Proposal
  37. Breseghello Luca, Hajikarimian Hamed, Naboni Roberto (2024-05)
    3DLightSlab:
    Design to 3D Concrete Printing Workflow for Stress-Driven Ribbed Slabs
  38. Vargas José, Sjölander Andreas, Westerlind Helena, Silfwerbrand Johan (2024-05)
    Internal Topology-Optimization of 3D Printed Concrete Structures:
    A Method for Enhanced Performance and Material-Efficiency
  39. Zuo Zibo, Corte Wouter, Huang Yulin, Chen Xiaoming et al. (2024-05)
    Strategies Towards Large-Scale 3D Printing Without Size-Constraints
  40. Zaid Osama, Ouni Mohamed (2024-04)
    Advancements in 3D Printing of Cementitious Materials:
    A Review of Mineral Additives, Properties, and Systematic Developments
  41. Alhussain Ali, Duarte José, Brown Nathan (2024-02)
    Developing a Data-Driven Filament-Shape-Prediction-Model for 3D Concrete Printing
  42. Jiang Xiongzhi, Li Yujia, Yang Zhe, Li Yangbo et al. (2024-02)
    Harnessing Path-Optimization to Enhance the Strength of Three-Dimensional Printed Concrete
  43. Vaněk Vojtěch, Chomová Štěpánka, Pěnčík Jan (2024-01)
    Additive Technologies in Construction:
    Shifting the Paradigm of Building
  44. Prihar Arjun, Garlock Maria, Najmeddine Aimane, Moini Mohamadreza (2024-01)
    Mechanical Performance of Sinusoidally Architected Concrete Enabled by Robotic Additive Manufacturing
  45. Westerlind Helena, Vargas José, Silfwerbrand Johan (2024-01)
    Towards the Application of Mesostructures in 3D Concrete Printing:
    Evaluating Load-bearing Performance
  46. Maitenaz Sébastien, Mesnil Romain, Féraille Adélaïde, Caron Jean-François (2023-12)
    Materialising Structural Optimization of Reinforced Concrete Beams Through Digital Fabrication
  47. Naboni Roberto, Zomparelli Alessandro, Kunic Anja, Breseghello Luca (2023-11)
    Design, Robotic Fabrication and Augmented Construction of Low-Carbon Concrete Slabs Through Field-Based Reaction-Diffusion
  48. Auer Daniel, Bos Freek, Olabi Mohammad, Fischer Oliver (2023-10)
    Fiber-Reinforcement of 3D Printed Concrete by Material-Extrusion-Tool-Paths Aligned to Principal Stress-Trajectories
  49. Hu Hailong, Huang Jian, Wang Tiezhu, Manuka Mesfin et al. (2023-09)
    Impact of Calcium Sulfoaluminate Cement on Printability and Early Strength Development of a Slag-Based 3D Printing Cementitious Material
  50. Breseghello Luca, Hajikarimian Hamed, Jørgensen Henrik, Naboni Roberto (2023-07)
    3DLightBeam+:
    Design, Simulation, and Testing of Carbon-Efficient Reinforced 3D Concrete Printed Beams
  51. Tu Haidong, Wei Zhenyun, Bahrami Alireza, Kahla Nabil et al. (2023-06)
    Recent Advancements and Future Trends in 3D Printing Concrete Using Waste-Materials
  52. Wan Qian, Yang Wenwei, Wang Li, Ma Guowei (2023-04)
    Global Continuous Path-Planning for 3D Concrete Printing Multi-Branched Structure
  53. Pons-Valladares Oriol, Casanovas-Rubio Maria, Armengou Jaume, Fuente Albert (2023-02)
    Approach for Sustainability-Assessment for Footbridge Construction Technologies:
    Application to the First World D-Shape 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Mortar Footbridge in Madrid
  54. Aramburu Amaia, Calderon-Uriszar-Aldaca Iñigo, Puente Iñigo (2023-02)
    Parametric Modelling of 3D Printed Concrete Segmented Beams with Rebars Under Bending Moments
  55. García-Alvarado Rodrigo, Moroni-Orellana Ginnia, Banda Pablo (2022-10)
    Development of Variable Residential Buildings with 3D Printed Walls
  56. Nuh Mishael, Oval Robin, Orr John, Shepherd Paul (2022-09)
    Digital Fabrication of Ribbed Concrete Shells Using Automated Robotic Concrete Spraying
  57. Gislason Styrmir, Bruhn Simon, Breseghello Luca, Sen Burak et al. (2022-06)
    Porous 3D Printed Concrete Beams Show an Environmental Promise:
    A Cradle-to-Grave Comparative Life Cycle Assessment

BibTeX
@article{bres_nabo.2022.TPBDf3CPoCEAS,
  author            = "Luca Breseghello and Roberto Naboni",
  title             = "Tool-Path -Based Design for 3D Concrete Printing of Carbon-Efficient Architectural Structures",
  doi               = "10.1016/j.addma.2022.102872",
  year              = "2022",
  journal           = "Additive Manufacturing",
  volume            = "56",
}
Formatted Citation

L. Breseghello and R. Naboni, “Tool-Path -Based Design for 3D Concrete Printing of Carbon-Efficient Architectural Structures”, Additive Manufacturing, vol. 56, 2022, doi: 10.1016/j.addma.2022.102872.

Breseghello, Luca, and Roberto Naboni. “Tool-Path -Based Design for 3D Concrete Printing of Carbon-Efficient Architectural Structures”. Additive Manufacturing 56 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.addma.2022.102872.