Skip to content

On-Line and In-Line Quality-Assessment Across All Scale Levels of 3D Concrete Printing (2024-08)

10.1016/j.cemconres.2024.107646

 Wolfs Robert,  Bos Derk,  Caron Jean-François,  Gerke Markus,  Mesnil Romain,  Buswell Richard,  Ducoulombier Nicolas,  Hack Norman,  Keita Emmanuel, Kinnell Peter,  Mawas Karam,  Mechtcherine Viktor,  de Miranda Luiza,  Sokolov Dmitrii,  Versteege Jelle,  Roussel Nicolas
Journal Article - Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 185, No. 107646

Abstract

3D Concrete printing requires much more elaborate quality control procedures compared to conventional concrete processing. Due to the various process steps, and the corresponding variation in material behaviour, time-, and length-scales, a single quality indicator and measurement technique (similar to the ‘slump test’ for traditional construction) cannot be selected. Instead, three families of quality indicators have been established: homogeneity during material production and deposition (quality variations), material evolution during printing (transient material behaviour), and macroscopic features and geometric conformity during printing and of the final object (geometry). For each family, quality assessment techniques which have been proven in other fields or for different applications, have been successfully transferred and adapted to the 3DCP process. In some cases, completely new methods have been developed. This paper aims to provide the state-of-the-art in such quality assessment methods, indicating high potential methods and research gaps across all scale levels of 3D concrete printing processes.

63 References

  1. Ahmed Zeeshan, Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2021-11)
    A Framework for Large-Scale Structural Applications of 3D Printed Concrete:
    The Case of a 29m Bridge in the Netherlands
  2. Bard Joshua, Cupkova Dana, Washburn Newell, Zeglin Garth (2018-12)
    Robotic Concrete Surface Finishing:
    A Moldless Approach to Creating Thermally Tuned Surface Geometry for Architectural Building Components Using Profile 3D Printing
  3. Bhooshan Shajay, Bhooshan Vishu, Dell’Endice Alessandro, Chu Jianfei et al. (2022-06)
    The Striatus Bridge
  4. Bos Freek, Menna Costantino, Pradena Mauricio, Kreiger Eric et al. (2022-03)
    The Realities of Additively Manufactured Concrete Structures in Practice
  5. Bos Derk, Wolfs Robert (2023-12)
    A Quality-Control Framework for Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  6. Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2016-08)
    Additive Manufacturing of Concrete in Construction:
    Potentials and Challenges of 3D Concrete Printing
  7. Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2018-09)
    Large-Scale Testing of Digitally Fabricated Concrete (DFC) Elements
  8. Buswell Richard, Kinnell Peter, Xu Jie, Hack Norman et al. (2020-07)
    Inspection Methods for 3D Concrete Printing
  9. Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Bos Freek, Schipper Roel et al. (2020-05)
    A Process Classification Framework for Defining and Describing Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  10. Buswell Richard, Xu Jie, Becker Daniel, Dobrzanski James et al. (2022-04)
    Geometric Quality Assurance for 3D Concrete Printing and Hybrid Construction Manufacturing Using a Standardised Test Part for Benchmarking Capability
  11. Carneau Paul, Mesnil Romain, Baverel Olivier, Roussel Nicolas (2022-03)
    Layer Pressing in Concrete Extrusion-Based 3D Printing:
    Experiments and Analysis
  12. Choi Myoungsung, Roussel Nicolas, Kim Youngjin, Kim Jinkeun (2013-01)
    Lubrication-Layer Properties During Concrete Pumping
  13. Comminal Raphaël, Serdeczny Marcin, Pedersen David, Spangenberg Jon (2019-06)
    Motion-Planning and Numerical Simulation of Material-Deposition at Corners in Extrusion Additive Manufacturing
  14. Davtalab Omid, Kazemian Ali, Yuan Xiao, Khoshnevis Behrokh (2020-10)
    Automated Inspection in Robotic Additive Manufacturing Using Deep Learning for Layer Deformation Detection
  15. Demont Léo, Mesnil Romain, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Caron Jean-François (2023-10)
    Affordable In-Line Structuration Measurements of Printable Mortar with a Pocket-Shear-Vane
  16. Ducoulombier Nicolas (2019-06)
    Characterisation and Modelling of Interfacial-Damage in Fiber-Reinforced Concrete for 3D Printing in Construction
  17. Ducoulombier Nicolas, Mesnil Romain, Carneau Paul, Demont Léo et al. (2021-05)
    The “Slugs-Test” for Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing:
    Protocol, Analysis and Practical Limits
  18. Fataei Shirin, Secrieru Egor, Mechtcherine Viktor, Roussel Nicolas (2021-07)
    A First-Order Physical Model for the Prediction of Shear-Induced Particle-Migration and Lubricating-Layer Formation During Concrete Pumping
  19. Feys Dimitri, Schutter Geert, Fataei Shirin, Martys Nicos et al. (2022-01)
    Pumping of Concrete:
    Understanding a Common Placement Method with Lots of Challenges
  20. García Rodrigo, Dokladalova Eva, Dokládal Petr, Caron Jean-François et al. (2022-09)
    In-Line Monitoring of 3D Concrete Printing Using Computer-Vision
  21. Geffrault Anatole, Bessaies-Bey Hela, Roussel Nicolas, Coussot Philippe (2023-08)
    Printing by Yield-Stress Fluid-Shaping
  22. Hack Norman, Jantzen Carsten, Brohmann Leon, Gerke Markus et al. (2022-06)
    A Closed-Loop Workflow for Quality Inspection and Integrated Post-Processing of 3D Printed Concrete Elements
  23. Hack Norman, Kloft Harald (2020-07)
    Shotcrete 3D Printing Technology for the Fabrication of Slender Fully Reinforced Freeform Concrete Elements with High Surface Quality:
    A Real-Scale Demonstrator
  24. Jacquet Yohan, Perrot Arnaud (2023-07)
    Sewing Concrete Device:
    Combining In-Line Rheology-Control and Reinforcement-System for 3D Concrete Printing
  25. Keita Emmanuel, Bessaies-Bey Hela, Zuo Wenqiang, Belin Patrick et al. (2019-06)
    Weak Bond Strength Between Successive Layers in Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing:
    Measurement and Physical Origin
  26. Kruger Jacques, Zijl Gideon (2020-10)
    A Compendious Review on Lack-of-Fusion in Digital Concrete Fabrication
  27. Kuzmenko Kateryna, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Féraille Adélaïde, Roussel Nicolas (2022-05)
    Environmental Impact of Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing:
    Generic Model, Power-Measurements and Influence of Printing-Resolution
  28. Lachmayer Lukas, Böhler David, Freund Niklas, Mai (née Dressler) Inka et al. (2022-11)
    Modelling the Influence of Material and Process Parameters on Shotcrete 3D Printed Strands:
    Cross-Section Adjustment for Automatic Robotic Manufacturing
  29. Lindemann Hendrik, Gerbers Roman, Ibrahim Serhat, Dietrich Franz et al. (2018-09)
    Development of a Shotcrete 3D Printing (SC3DP) Technology for Additive Manufacturing of Reinforced Freeform Concrete Structures
  30. Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Wangler Timothy, Gebhard Lukas, Mata-Falcón Jaime et al. (2020-05)
    From Smart Dynamic Casting to a Growing Family of Digital Casting Systems
  31. Lowke Dirk, Dini Enrico, Perrot Arnaud, Weger Daniel et al. (2018-07)
    Particle-Bed 3D Printing in Concrete Construction:
    Possibilities and Challenges
  32. Ma Guowei, Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Wang Li et al. (2022-03)
    Technology Readiness:
    A Global Snapshot of 3D Concrete Printing and the Frontiers for Development
  33. Mawas Karam, Maboudi Mehdi, Gerke Markus (2022-05)
    Automatic Geometric Inspection in Digital Fabrication
  34. Mawas Karam, Maboudi Mehdi, Gerke Markus (2023-09)
    Filament Extraction in 3D Printing of Shotcrete Walls from Terrestrial Laser Scanner Data
  35. Mechtcherine Viktor, Bos Freek, Perrot Arnaud, Silva Wilson et al. (2020-03)
    Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing with Cement-Based Materials:
    Production Steps, Processes, and Their Underlying Physics
  36. Mechtcherine Viktor, Tittelboom Kim, Kazemian Ali, Kreiger Eric et al. (2022-04)
    A Roadmap for Quality-Control of Hardening and Hardened Printed Concrete
  37. Menna Costantino, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Bos Freek, Vantyghem Gieljan et al. (2020-04)
    Opportunities and Challenges for Structural Engineering of Digitally Fabricated Concrete
  38. Nair Sooraj, Sant Gaurav, Neithalath Narayanan (2021-11)
    Mathematical Morphology-Based Point-Cloud-Analysis-Techniques for Geometry-Assessment of 3D Printed Concrete Elements
  39. Nerella Venkatesh, Näther Mathias, Iqbal Arsalan, Butler Marko et al. (2018-09)
    In-Line Quantification of Extrudability of Cementitious Materials for Digital Construction
  40. Perrot Arnaud, Rangeard Damien, Pierre Alexandre (2015-02)
    Structural Build-Up of Cement-Based Materials Used for 3D Printing-Extrusion-Techniques
  41. Pott Ursula, Stephan Dietmar (2021-04)
    Penetration-Test as a Fast Method to Determine Yield-Stress and Structural Build-Up for 3D Printing of Cementitious Materials
  42. Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu, Meena Hitesh, Ghani Zimam (2018-12)
    3D Printable Concrete:
    Mixture-Design and Test-Methods
  43. Rehman Atta, Kim Ik-Gyeom, Kim Jung-Hoon (2024-01)
    Towards Full Automation in 3D Concrete Printing Construction:
    Development of an Automated and In-Line Test-Method for In-Situ Assessment of Structural Build-Up and Quality of Concrete
  44. Reiter Lex, Wangler Timothy, Anton Ana-Maria, Flatt Robert (2020-05)
    Setting-on-Demand for Digital Concrete:
    Principles, Measurements, Chemistry, Validation
  45. Reiter Lex, Wangler Timothy, Roussel Nicolas, Flatt Robert (2018-06)
    The Role of Early-Age Structural Build-Up in Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  46. Reiter Lex, Wangler Timothy, Roussel Nicolas, Flatt Robert (2022-04)
    Slow Penetration for Characterizing Concrete for Digital Fabrication
  47. Roussel Nicolas (2018-05)
    Rheological Requirements for Printable Concretes
  48. Roussel Nicolas, Buswell Richard, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Ivanova Irina et al. (2022-06)
    Assessing the Fresh Properties of Printable Cement-Based Materials:
    High-Potential Tests for Quality-Control
  49. Senthilnathan Shanmugaraj, Raphael Benny (2022-11)
    Using Computer-Vision for Monitoring the Quality of 3D Printed Concrete Structures
  50. Slepicka Martin, Mawas Karam, Borrmann André, Maboudi Mehdi et al. (2023-09)
    Digital Twinning in Additive Manufacturing:
    Closing the Digital-Physical-Digital Loop by Automated Integration of Captured Geometric Data into Fabrication Information Models
  51. Suiker Akke (2018-01)
    Mechanical Performance of Wall Structures in 3D Printing Processes:
    Theory, Design Tools and Experiments
  52. Suiker Akke, Wolfs Robert, Lucas Sandra, Salet Theo (2020-06)
    Elastic Buckling and Plastic Collapse During 3D Concrete Printing
  53. Szabó Anna, Reiter Lex, Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Wangler Timothy et al. (2020-07)
    ACDC:
    The Admixture-Controlled Digital Casting and Its Application to Thin-Folded Concrete Structures
  54. Wangler Timothy, Pileggi Rafael, Gürel Şeyma, Flatt Robert (2022-03)
    A Chemical Process Engineering Look at Digital Concrete Processes:
    Critical Step Design, In-Line Mixing, and Scale-Up
  55. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2018-06)
    Correlation Between Destructive Compression Tests and Non-Destructive Ultrasonic Measurements on Early-Age 3D Printed Concrete
  56. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2018-02)
    Early-Age Mechanical Behaviour of 3D Printed Concrete:
    Numerical Modelling and Experimental Testing
  57. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2019-03)
    Hardened Properties of 3D Printed Concrete:
    The Influence of Process Parameters on Inter-Layer Adhesion
  58. Wolfs Robert, Bos Freek, Salet Theo (2019-06)
    Triaxial Compression Testing on Early-Age Concrete for Numerical Analysis of 3D Concrete Printing
  59. Wolfs Robert, Bos Derk, Salet Theo (2023-06)
    Lessons Learned of Project Milestone:
    The First 3D Printed Concrete House in the Netherlands
  60. Wolfs Robert, Salet Theo, Roussel Nicolas (2021-10)
    Filament-Geometry-Control in Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing of Concrete:
    The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
  61. Wolfs Robert, Suiker Akke (2019-06)
    Structural Failure During Extrusion-Based 3D Printing Processes
  62. Xiao Jianzhuang, Ji Guangchao, Zhang Yamei, Ma Guowei et al. (2021-06)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing Concrete Technology:
    Current Status and Future Opportunities
  63. Xu Jie, Buswell Richard, Kinnell Peter, Biro Istvan et al. (2020-06)
    Inspecting Manufacturing Precision of 3D Printed Concrete Parts Based on Geometric Dimensioning and Tolerancing

23 Citations

  1. Liu Xingzi, Buswell Richard, Cavalaro Sergio, Xu Jie et al. (2026-01)
    Influence of Inter-Filament Voids on the Failure Mechanism and Compressive Strength of 3D Printed Concrete
  2. Kaushik Sandipan, Sonebi Mohammed, Amato Giuseppina, Perrot Arnaud (2026-01)
    Effect of Fly Ash, Basalt Fiber and Attapulgite Nanoclay on the Fresh Properties, Rheology and Shrinkage Behaviour of Printable Concrete
  3. Ding Yao, Liu Yifan, Yang Bo, Liu Jiepeng et al. (2026-01)
    Application of Artificial Intelligence Technology in 3D Concrete Printing Quality Inspection and Control:
    A State-of-the-Art Review
  4. Kamhawi Abdallah, Lin Yuxin, Watson Christopher, Barton Kira et al. (2025-12)
    A Framework for Process Anomaly Detection in 3D Concrete Printing
  5. Taborda-Llano Isabella, Hoyos-Montilla Ary, Asensio Eloy, Guerrero Ana et al. (2025-12)
    Influence of the Construction Process Parameters on the Mechanical Performance and Durability of 3D Printed Concrete:
    A Systematic Review
  6. Deetman Arjen, Bos Derk, Lucas Sandra, Salet Theo et al. (2025-12)
    A Database Framework for 3D Concrete Printing
  7. Banijamali Kasra, Martin Michael, Mascarenas David, Kazemian Ali (2025-11)
    Automated Inspection in Robotic 3D Printing:
    In-Process Geometrical Measurements Using Structured Light Machine Vision
  8. Diggs-McGee Brandy, Samouh Hamza, Garg Nishant (2025-11)
    Predicting Cementitious Set Times via Infrared Thermography:
    Potential Implications on Real-Time Quality Control During 3D Concrete Printing
  9. Zhang Chao, Zhu Xiaohong, Li Muduo, Zhang Yuying et al. (2025-10)
    Enhancing Interface Adhesion of 3D Printable Concrete by Biochar Integration
  10. Mawas Karam, Maboudi Mehdi, Gerke Markus (2025-09)
    A Review on Geometry and Surface Inspection in 3D Concrete Printing
  11. Márquez Álvaro, Varela Hugo, Barluenga Gonzalo (2025-09)
    Influence of Rheology Modifying Admixtures on the Buildability of 3D Printing Cement-Based Mortars
  12. Rabiei Mahsa, Moini Mohamadreza (2025-09)
    Extrusion Under Material Uncertainty with Pressure-Based Closed-Loop Feedback Control in Robotic Concrete Additive Manufacturing
  13. Maboudi Mehdi, Mawas Karam, Gerke Markus (2025-07)
    Geometric Inspection in 3D Concrete Manufacturing:
    Comparison of Data Capturing Techniques
  14. Sando Mona, Stephan Dietmar (2025-07)
    Online Monitoring for 3D Printable Geopolymers:
    Automated Slug Test Analysis with Image Analysis Revealing Mixing Sequence Effects
  15. Versteege Jelle, Wolfs Robert, Salet Theo (2025-06)
    Data-Driven Additive Manufacturing with Concrete - Enhancing In-Line Sensory Data with Domain Knowledge:
    Part II: Moisture and Heat
  16. Surehali Sahil, Venkatachalam Akshay, Divigalpitiya Ranjith, Kumar Aditya et al. (2025-06)
    Ultra-Low Dosages of Novel Graphene Types Enhance the Rheological Properties and Buildability of 3D Printed Binders
  17. Dobrzanski James, Xu Jie, Bartek Rasti, Becker Daniel et al. (2025-04)
    From Digital Crafting to Digital Manufacturing:
    Automated Production Using Hybrid 3D Concrete Printing
  18. Vasilić Ksenija (2025-02)
    Standardization Aspects of Concrete 3D Printing
  19. Banijamali Kasra, Dempsey Mary, Chen Jianhua, Kazemian Ali (2025-02)
    Machine Learning Approach to Predict the Early-Age Flexural Strength of Sensor-Embedded 3D-Printed Structures
  20. Versteege Jelle, Wolfs Robert, Salet Theo (2025-02)
    Data-Driven Additive Manufacturing with Concrete - Enhancing In-Line Sensory Data with Domain Knowledge:
    Part I: Geometry
  21. Lori Ali, Mehrali Mehdi (2025-01)
    Filament-Geometry-Control of Printable Geopolymer Using Experimental and Data-Driven Approaches
  22. Martin Michael, Banijamali Kasra, Gilbert Hunter, Mascarenas David et al. (2024-09)
    LiDAR-Based Real-Time Geometrical Inspection for Large-Scale Additive Manufacturing
  23. Wolfs Robert (2024-09)
    The Status Quo of 3D Concrete Printing:
    Are We There Yet?

BibTeX
@article{wolf_bos_caro_gerk.2024.OLaILQAAASLo3CP,
  author            = "Robert Johannes Maria Wolfs and Derk H. Bos and Jean-François Caron and Markus Gerke and Romain Mesnil and Richard A. Buswell and Nicolas Ducoulombier and Norman Peter Hack and Emmanuel Keita and Peter Kinnell and Karam Mawas and Viktor Mechtcherine and Luiza R. M. de Miranda and Dmitrii Sokolov and Jelle Versteege and Nicolas Roussel",
  title             = "On-Line and In-Line Quality-Assessment Across All Scale Levels of 3D Concrete Printing",
  doi               = "10.1016/j.cemconres.2024.107646",
  year              = "2024",
  journal           = "Cement and Concrete Research",
  volume            = "185",
  pages             = "107646",
}
Formatted Citation

R. J. M. Wolfs, “On-Line and In-Line Quality-Assessment Across All Scale Levels of 3D Concrete Printing”, Cement and Concrete Research, vol. 185, p. 107646, 2024, doi: 10.1016/j.cemconres.2024.107646.

Wolfs, Robert Johannes Maria, Derk H. Bos, Jean-François Caron, Markus Gerke, Romain Mesnil, Richard A. Buswell, Nicolas Ducoulombier, et al.. “On-Line and In-Line Quality-Assessment Across All Scale Levels of 3D Concrete Printing”. Cement and Concrete Research 185 (2024): 107646. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2024.107646.