Skip to content

Selection of Digital Fabrication Technique in the Construction Industry (2024-07)

A Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Approach

10.1007/s11709-024-1075-1

 Salaimanimagudam M.,  Jayaprakash Jaganathan
Journal Article - Frontiers of Structural and Civil Engineering

Abstract

Digital fabrication techniques, in recent decades, have provided the basis of a sustainable revolution in the construction industry. However, selecting the digital fabrication method in terms of manufacturability and functionality requirements is a complex problem. This paper presents alternatives and criteria for selection of digital fabrication techniques by adopting the multi-criteria decision-making technique. The alternatives considered in the study are concrete three-dimensional (3D) printing, shotcrete, smart dynamic casting, material intrusion, mesh molding, injection concrete 3D printing, and thin forming techniques. The criteria include formwork utilization, reinforcement incorporation, geometrical complexity, material enhancement, assembly complexity, surface finish, and build area. It demonstrates different multi-criteria decision-making techniques, with both subjective and objective weighting methods. The given ranking is based on the current condition of digital fabrication in the construction industry. The study reveals that in the selection of digital fabrication techniques, the criteria including reinforcement incorporation, build area, and geometrical complexity play a pivotal role, collectively accounting for nearly 70% of the overall weighting. Among the evaluated techniques, concrete 3D printing emerged as the best performer, however the shotcrete and mesh molding techniques in the second and third positions.

59 References

  1. Anton Ana-Maria, Bedarf Patrick, Yoo Angela, Dillenburger Benjamin et al. (2020-09)
    Concrete Choreography:
    Prefabrication of 3D Printed Columns
  2. Anton Ana-Maria, Reiter Lex, Wangler Timothy, Frangez Valens et al. (2020-12)
    A 3D Concrete Printing Prefabrication Platform for Bespoke Columns
  3. Arunothayan Arun, Nematollahi Behzad, Ranade Ravi, Bong Shin et al. (2020-10)
    Development of 3D Printable Ultra-High-Performance Fiber-Reinforced Concrete for Digital Construction
  4. Asprone Domenico, Auricchio Ferdinando, Menna Costantino, Mercuri Valentina (2018-03)
    3D Printing of Reinforced Concrete Elements:
    Technology and Design Approach
  5. Bazli Milad, Ashrafi Hamed, Rajabipour Ali, Kutay Cat (2023-02)
    3D Printing for Remote Housing:
    Benefits and Challenges
  6. Bos Freek, Wolfs Robert, Ahmed Zeeshan, Salet Theo (2016-08)
    Additive Manufacturing of Concrete in Construction:
    Potentials and Challenges of 3D Concrete Printing
  7. Burger Joris, Aejmelaeus-Lindström Johan, Gürel Şeyma, Niketić Filip et al. (2023-02)
    Eggshell Pavilion:
    A Reinforced Concrete Structure Fabricated Using Robotically 3D Printed Formwork
  8. Burger Joris, Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Scotto Fabio, Demoulin Thibault et al. (2020-04)
    Eggshell:
    Ultra-Thin Three-Dimensional Printed Formwork for Concrete Structures
  9. Burger Joris, Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Taha Nizar, Scotto Fabio et al. (2020-07)
    Design and Fabrication of a Non-Standard, Structural Concrete Column Using Eggshell:
    Ultra-Thin, 3D Printed Formwork
  10. Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Jones Scott, Dirrenberger Justin (2018-06)
    3D Printing Using Concrete-Extrusion:
    A Roadmap for Research
  11. Daungwilailuk Totsawat, Pheinsusom Phoonsak, Pansuk Withit (2021-01)
    Uniaxial Load Testing of Large-Scale 3D Printed Concrete Wall and Finite-Element-Model-Analysis
  12. Dörfler Kathrin, Hack Norman, Sandy Timothy, Giftthaler Markus et al. (2019-09)
    Mobile Robotic Fabrication Beyond Factory Conditions:
    Case Study Mesh Mould Wall of the DFAB HOUSE
  13. Gebhard Lukas, Burger Joris, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Lloret-Fritschi Ena et al. (2022-03)
    Towards Efficient Concrete Structures with Ultra-Thin 3D Printed Formwork:
    Exploring Reinforcement-Strategies and Optimization
  14. Gebhard Lukas, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Anton Ana-Maria, Dillenburger Benjamin et al. (2021-04)
    Structural Behavior of 3D Printed Concrete Beams with Various Reinforcement-Strategies
  15. Gosselin Clément, Duballet Romain, Roux Philippe, Gaudillière-Jami Nadja et al. (2016-03)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing of Ultra-High-Performance Concrete:
    A New Processing Route for Architects and Builders
  16. Hack Norman, Dörfler Kathrin, Walzer Alexander, Wangler Timothy et al. (2020-03)
    Structural Stay-in-Place Formwork for Robotic In-Situ Fabrication of Non-Standard Concrete Structures:
    A Real-Scale Architectural Demonstrator
  17. Hack Norman, Mai (née Dressler) Inka, Brohmann Leon, Gantner Stefan et al. (2020-03)
    Injection 3D Concrete Printing (I3DCP):
    Basic Principles and Case Studies
  18. He Lewei, Chow Wai, Li Hua (2020-06)
    Effects of Inter-Layer Notch and Shear Stress on Inter-Layer Strength of 3D Printed Cement-Paste
  19. He Lewei, Tan Jolyn, Chow Wai, Li Hua et al. (2021-11)
    Design of Novel Nozzles for Higher Inter-Layer Strength of 3D Printed Cement-Paste
  20. Heidarnezhad Fatemeh, Zhang Qian (2022-01)
    Shotcrete-Based 3D Concrete Printing:
    State of Art, Challenges, and Opportunities
  21. Huang Xin, Yang Weihao, Song Fangnian, Zou Jiuqun (2022-04)
    Study on the Mechanical Properties of 3D Printing Concrete Layers and the Mechanism of Influence of Printing Parameters
  22. Kaliyavaradhan Senthil, Ambily Parukutty, Prem Prabhat, Ghodke Swapnil (2022-08)
    Test-Methods for 3D Printable Concrete
  23. Khoshnevis Behrokh (2003-11)
    Automated Construction by Contour Crafting:
    Related Robotics and Information Technologies
  24. Kloft Harald, Hack Norman, Mainka Jeldrik, Brohmann Leon et al. (2019-11)
    Additive Manufacturing in Construction:
    First 3D-Printed Reinforced Concrete Components Using Shotcrete 3D Printing (SC3DP) Technology
  25. Kloft Harald, Krauss Hans-Werner, Hack Norman, Herrmann Eric et al. (2020-05)
    Influence of Process Parameters on the Inter-Layer Bond Strength of Concrete Elements Additive Manufactured by Shotcrete 3D Printing
  26. Kristombu Baduge Shanaka, Navaratnam Satheeskumar, Zidan Yousef, McCormack Tom et al. (2021-01)
    Improving Performance of Additive Manufactured Concrete:
    A Review on Material Mix-Design, Processing, Inter-Layer Bonding, and Reinforcing-Methods
  27. Lindemann Hendrik, Gerbers Roman, Ibrahim Serhat, Dietrich Franz et al. (2018-09)
    Development of a Shotcrete 3D Printing (SC3DP) Technology for Additive Manufacturing of Reinforced Freeform Concrete Structures
  28. Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Scotto Fabio, Gramazio Fabio, Kohler Matthias et al. (2018-09)
    Challenges of Real-Scale Production with Smart Dynamic Casting
  29. Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Shahab Amir, Linus Mettler, Flatt Robert et al. (2014-03)
    Complex Concrete Structures:
    Merging Existing Casting Techniques with Digital Fabrication
  30. Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Wangler Timothy, Gebhard Lukas, Mata-Falcón Jaime et al. (2020-05)
    From Smart Dynamic Casting to a Growing Family of Digital Casting Systems
  31. Lowke Dirk, Dini Enrico, Perrot Arnaud, Weger Daniel et al. (2018-07)
    Particle-Bed 3D Printing in Concrete Construction:
    Possibilities and Challenges
  32. Lowke Dirk, Talke Daniel, Mai (née Dressler) Inka, Weger Daniel et al. (2020-05)
    Particle-Bed 3D Printing by Selective Cement-Activation:
    Applications, Material and Process Technology
  33. Lowke Dirk, Vandenberg Aileen, Pierre Alexandre, Thomas Amaury et al. (2021-07)
    Injection 3D Concrete Printing in a Carrier Liquid:
    Underlying Physics and Applications to Lightweight Space Frame Structures
  34. Marchment Taylor, Sanjayan Jay, Xia Ming (2019-03)
    Method of Enhancing Inter-Layer Bond Strength in Construction-Scale 3D Printing with Mortar by Effective Bond Area Amplification
  35. Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh, Will Frank, Näther Mathias et al. (2019-08)
    Large-Scale Digital Concrete Construction:
    CONPrint3D Concept for On-Site, Monolithic 3D Printing
  36. Menna Costantino, Mata-Falcón Jaime, Bos Freek, Vantyghem Gieljan et al. (2020-04)
    Opportunities and Challenges for Structural Engineering of Digitally Fabricated Concrete
  37. Nair Sooraj, Alghamdi Hussam, Arora Aashay, Mehdipour Iman et al. (2019-01)
    Linking Fresh Paste Microstructure, Rheology and Extrusion-Characteristics of Cementitious Binders for 3D Printing
  38. Nair Sooraj, Panda Subhashree, Santhanam Manu, Sant Gaurav et al. (2020-05)
    A Critical Examination of the Influence of Material-Characteristics and Extruder-Geometry on 3D Printing of Cementitious Binders
  39. Neudecker Stefan, Bruns Christopher, Gerbers Roman, Heyn Jakob et al. (2016-05)
    A New Robotic Spray Technology for Generative Manufacturing of Complex Concrete-Structures without Formwork
  40. Pan Tinghong, Jiang Yaqing, He Hui, Wang Yu et al. (2021-01)
    Effect of Structural Build-Up on Inter-Layer Bond Strength of 3D Printed Cement Mortars
  41. Panda Biranchi, Tay Yi, Paul Suvash, Tan Ming (2018-05)
    Current Challenges and Future Potential of 3D Concrete Printing
  42. Pons-Valladares Oriol, Casanovas-Rubio Maria, Armengou Jaume, Fuente Albert (2023-02)
    Approach for Sustainability-Assessment for Footbridge Construction Technologies:
    Application to the First World D-Shape 3D Printed Fiber-Reinforced Mortar Footbridge in Madrid
  43. Prasittisopin Lapyote, Sakdanaraseth Thanut, Horayangkura Vimolsiddhi (2021-06)
    Design and Construction Method of a 3D Concrete Printing Self-Supporting Curvi-Linear Pavilion
  44. Putten Jolien, Volder Melissa, Heede Philip, Deprez Maxim et al. (2022-03)
    Transport Properties of 3D Printed Cementitious Materials with Prolonged Time-Gap Between Successive Layers
  45. Reiter Lex, Wangler Timothy, Anton Ana-Maria, Flatt Robert (2020-05)
    Setting-on-Demand for Digital Concrete:
    Principles, Measurements, Chemistry, Validation
  46. Roussel Nicolas (2018-05)
    Rheological Requirements for Printable Concretes
  47. Salaimanimagudam M., Jayaprakash Jaganathan (2022-11)
    Optimum Selection of Reinforcement, Assembly, and Formwork System for Digital Fabrication Technique in Construction Industry:
    A Critical Review
  48. Salet Theo, Ahmed Zeeshan, Bos Freek, Laagland Hans (2018-05)
    Design of a 3D Printed Concrete Bridge by Testing
  49. Schutter Geert, Lesage Karel, Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh et al. (2018-08)
    Vision of 3D Printing with Concrete:
    Technical, Economic and Environmental Potentials
  50. Tay Yi, Lim Jian, Li Mingyang, Tan Ming (2022-03)
    Creating Functionally Graded Concrete Materials with Varying 3D Printing Parameters
  51. Tay Yi, Qian Ye, Tan Ming (2019-05)
    Printability-Region for 3D Concrete Printing Using Slump- and Slump-Flow-Test
  52. Tho Tuong, Thinh Nguyen (2021-01)
    Using a Cable-Driven Parallel Robot with Applications in 3D Concrete Printing
  53. Tuvayanond Wiput, Prasittisopin Lapyote (2023-02)
    Design for Manufacture and Assembly of Digital Fabrication and Additive Manufacturing in Construction:
    A Review
  54. Vantyghem Gieljan, Corte Wouter, Shakour Emad, Amir Oded (2020-01)
    3D Printing of a Post-Tensioned Concrete Girder Designed by Topology-Optimization
  55. Wangler Timothy, Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Reiter Lex, Hack Norman et al. (2016-10)
    Digital Concrete:
    Opportunities and Challenges
  56. Weger Daniel, Gehlen Christoph, Korte Waldemar, Meyer-Brötz Fabian et al. (2022-02)
    Building Rethought:
    3D Concrete Printing in Building Practice
  57. Wolfs Robert, Bos Derk, Salet Theo (2023-06)
    Lessons Learned of Project Milestone:
    The First 3D Printed Concrete House in the Netherlands
  58. Yoris-Nobile Adrian, Lizasoain-Arteaga Esther, Slebi-Acevedo Carlos, Blanco-Fernandez Elena et al. (2022-07)
    Life-Cycle-Assessment and Multi-Criteria Decision-Making-Analysis to Determine the Performance of 3D Printed Cement Mortars and Geopolymers
  59. Zhan Qiang, Zhou Xinjie, Yuan Philip, Zhou Xinjie (2021-04)
    Design and Fabrication of a 3D Concrete Printed Pre-Stressed Bridge

1 Citations

  1. Prasittisopin Lapyote (2024-11)
    How 3D Printing Technology Makes Cities Smarter:
    A Review, Thematic Analysis, and Perspectives

BibTeX
@article{sala_jaya.2024.SoDFTitCI,
  author            = "M. P. Salaimanimagudam and Jaganathan Jayaprakash",
  title             = "Selection of Digital Fabrication Technique in the Construction Industry: A Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Approach",
  doi               = "10.1007/s11709-024-1075-1",
  year              = "2024",
  journal           = "Frontiers of Structural and Civil Engineering",
}
Formatted Citation

M. P. Salaimanimagudam and J. Jayaprakash, “Selection of Digital Fabrication Technique in the Construction Industry: A Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Approach”, Frontiers of Structural and Civil Engineering, 2024, doi: 10.1007/s11709-024-1075-1.

Salaimanimagudam, M. P., and Jaganathan Jayaprakash. “Selection of Digital Fabrication Technique in the Construction Industry: A Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Approach”. Frontiers of Structural and Civil Engineering, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11709-024-1075-1.