Skip to content

Methodology for Formulating Low-Carbon Printable Mortar Through Particles-Packing-Optimization (2023-12)

10.1016/j.cemconres.2023.107403

 de Bono Victor,  Ducoulombier Nicolas,  Mesnil Romain,  Caron Jean-François
Journal Article - Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 176, No. 107403

Abstract

High packing density is one of the key factors for obtaining ultra-high-performance cementitious materials in the hardened state. Packing density also plays a role in the fresh state, influencing various properties of dense suspensions, including rheological properties and stability, which are highly important in 3d printing applications. The maximum packing density of a specific mixture can be estimated by considering the geometrical properties and proportions of each component using the compressive packing model (CPM). This paper aims to utilize the CPM as an efficient tool for designing cementitious materials specifically tailored for large-scale 3D printing of mortar in bi-component printing systems, with a focus on maximizing the performance-to-environmental impact ratio. Two different sets of mixtures were prepared for this study. Set A consisted of cement, sand, and silica fume, while Set B utilized cement, multiple sands, and multiple limestone fillers. Within each group, various mixtures were tested on a small scale to validate their rheological properties, particularly the yield stress. Pumpability, extrudability and buildability were evaluated by utilizing these mixtures in different printing sessions. Additionally, the compressive strengths of these mixtures were characterized. Finally, a method for designing a printable mixture is presented, and efficient and printable formulations with low cement ratio are proposed and printed.

37 References

  1. Arunothayan Arun, Nematollahi Behzad, Ranade Ravi, Khayat Kamal et al. (2021-10)
    Digital Fabrication of Eco-Friendly Ultra-High-Performance Fiber-Reinforced Concrete
  2. Bhattacherjee Shantanu, Basavaraj Anusha, Rahul Attupurathu, Santhanam Manu et al. (2021-06)
    Sustainable Materials for 3D Concrete Printing
  3. Bhattacherjee Shantanu, Jain Smrati, Santhanam Manu (2022-06)
    Criticality of Microstructural Evolution at an Early-Age on the Buildability of an Accelerated 3D Printable Concrete
  4. Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Bos Freek, Schipper Roel et al. (2020-05)
    A Process Classification Framework for Defining and Describing Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  5. Buswell Richard, Silva Wilson, Jones Scott, Dirrenberger Justin (2018-06)
    3D Printing Using Concrete-Extrusion:
    A Roadmap for Research
  6. Carneau Paul, Mesnil Romain, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Roussel Nicolas et al. (2020-07)
    Characterisation of the Layer-Pressing-Strategy for Concrete 3D Printing
  7. Caron Jean-François, Demont Léo, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Mesnil Romain (2021-06)
    3D Printing of Mortar with Continuous Fibers:
    Principle, Properties and Potential for Application
  8. Demont Léo, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Mesnil Romain, Caron Jean-François (2021-01)
    Flow-Based Pultrusion of Continuous Fibers for Cement-Based Composite Material and Additive Manufacturing:
    Rheological and Technological Requirements
  9. Demont Léo, Mesnil Romain, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Caron Jean-François (2023-10)
    Affordable In-Line Structuration Measurements of Printable Mortar with a Pocket-Shear-Vane
  10. Ducoulombier Nicolas (2019-06)
    Characterisation and Modelling of Interfacial-Damage in Fiber-Reinforced Concrete for 3D Printing in Construction
  11. Ducoulombier Nicolas, Mesnil Romain, Carneau Paul, Demont Léo et al. (2021-05)
    The “Slugs-Test” for Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing:
    Protocol, Analysis and Practical Limits
  12. Flatt Robert, Wangler Timothy (2022-05)
    On Sustainability and Digital Fabrication with Concrete
  13. Gaudillière-Jami Nadja, Duballet Romain, Bouyssou Charles, Mallet Alban et al. (2018-09)
    Large-Scale Additive Manufacturing of Ultra-High-Performance Concrete of Integrated Formwork for Truss-Shaped Pillars
  14. Gosselin Clément, Duballet Romain, Roux Philippe, Gaudillière-Jami Nadja et al. (2016-03)
    Large-Scale 3D Printing of Ultra-High-Performance Concrete:
    A New Processing Route for Architects and Builders
  15. Ivanova Irina, Ivaniuk Egor, Bisetti Sameercharan, Nerella Venkatesh et al. (2022-03)
    Comparison Between Methods for Indirect Assessment of Buildability in Fresh 3D Printed Mortar and Concrete
  16. Kolawole John, Becker Daniel, Xu Jie, Dobrzanski James et al. (2022-06)
    Selected Test-Methods for Assessing Fresh and Plastic-State 3D Concrete Printing-Materials
  17. Kondepudi Kala, Subramaniam Kolluru, Nematollahi Behzad, Bong Shin et al. (2022-05)
    Study of Particle-Packing and Paste-Rheology in Alkali-Activated Mixtures to Meet the Rheology Demands of 3D Concrete Printing
  18. Kuzmenko Kateryna, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Féraille Adélaïde, Roussel Nicolas (2022-05)
    Environmental Impact of Extrusion-Based Additive Manufacturing:
    Generic Model, Power-Measurements and Influence of Printing-Resolution
  19. Le Thanh, Austin Simon, Lim Sungwoo, Buswell Richard et al. (2012-01)
    Mix-Design and Fresh Properties for High-Performance Printing Concrete
  20. Mechtcherine Viktor, Buswell Richard, Kloft Harald, Bos Freek et al. (2021-02)
    Integrating Reinforcement in Digital Fabrication with Concrete:
    A Review and Classification Framework
  21. Moelich Gerrit, Kruger Jacques, Combrinck Riaan (2020-08)
    Plastic Shrinkage Cracking in 3D Printed Concrete
  22. Mohan Manu, Rahul Attupurathu, Tittelboom Kim, Schutter Geert (2020-10)
    Rheological and Pumping Behavior of 3D Printable Cementitious Materials with Varying Aggregate Content
  23. Nair Sooraj, Panda Subhashree, Santhanam Manu, Sant Gaurav et al. (2020-05)
    A Critical Examination of the Influence of Material-Characteristics and Extruder-Geometry on 3D Printing of Cementitious Binders
  24. Nerella Venkatesh, Krause Martin, Mechtcherine Viktor (2019-11)
    Direct Printing-Test for Buildability of 3D Printable Concrete Considering Economic Viability
  25. Perrot Arnaud, Pierre Alexandre, Nerella Venkatesh, Wolfs Robert et al. (2021-07)
    From Analytical Methods to Numerical Simulations:
    A Process Engineering Toolbox for 3D Concrete Printing
  26. Perrot Arnaud, Rangeard Damien, Pierre Alexandre (2015-02)
    Structural Build-Up of Cement-Based Materials Used for 3D Printing-Extrusion-Techniques
  27. Roussel Nicolas (2018-05)
    Rheological Requirements for Printable Concretes
  28. Roux Charlotte, Kuzmenko Kateryna, Roussel Nicolas, Mesnil Romain et al. (2022-11)
    Life Cycle Assessment of a Concrete 3D Printing Process
  29. Rubin Ariane, Quintanilha Lucas, Repette Wellington (2022-11)
    Influence of Structuration-Rate, with Hydration-Accelerating Admixture, on the Physical and Mechanical Properties of Concrete for 3D Printing
  30. Schutter Geert, Lesage Karel, Mechtcherine Viktor, Nerella Venkatesh et al. (2018-08)
    Vision of 3D Printing with Concrete:
    Technical, Economic and Environmental Potentials
  31. Silva Wilson, Kaasgaard Martin, Andersen Thomas (2022-06)
    Sustainable 3D Concrete Printing with Large Aggregates
  32. Souza Marcelo, Ferreira Igor, Moraes Elisângela, Senff Luciano et al. (2021-11)
    Role of Chemical Admixtures on 3D Printed Portland Cement:
    Assessing Rheology and Buildability
  33. Szabó Anna, Reiter Lex, Lloret-Fritschi Ena, Gramazio Fabio et al. (2020-04)
    Mastering Yield-Stress-Evolution and Formwork-Friction for Smart Dynamic Casting
  34. Wangler Timothy, Pileggi Rafael, Gürel Şeyma, Flatt Robert (2022-03)
    A Chemical Process Engineering Look at Digital Concrete Processes:
    Critical Step Design, In-Line Mixing, and Scale-Up
  35. Weng Yiwei, Li Mingyang, Tan Ming, Qian Shunzhi (2018-01)
    Design 3D Printing Cementitious Materials via Fuller-Thompson-Theory and Marson-Percy-Model
  36. Zhang Chao, Jia Zijian, Wang Xianggang, Jia Lutao et al. (2022-05)
    A Two-Phase Design-Strategy Based on the Composite of Mortar and Coarse Aggregate for 3D Printable Concrete with Coarse Aggregate
  37. Zhang Chao, Nerella Venkatesh, Krishna Anurag, Wang Shen et al. (2021-06)
    Mix-Design Concepts for 3D Printable Concrete:
    A Review

9 Citations

  1. Caneda-Martínez Laura, Hassan M., Demont Léo, Keita Emmanuel et al. (2026-01)
    Fast Penetration Testing of Printable Concretes with a Portable Device:
    Robustness and Calibration
  2. Bradshaw James, Balasubramanian Swathi, Si Wen, Khan Mehran et al. (2025-10)
    Towards Greener 3D Printing:
    A Performance Evaluation of Silica Fume-Modified Low-Carbon Concrete
  3. Mesnil Romain, Rosa Pedro, Demont Léo (2025-03)
    Thickness Optimisation in 3D Printed Concrete Structures
  4. Jin Willy, Caron Jean-François, Ouellet-Plamondon Claudiane (2024-11)
    Minimizing the Carbon Footprint of 3D Printing Concrete:
    Leveraging Parametric LCA and Neural Networks Through Multi-Objective-Optimization
  5. Bono Victor, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Loulha Sarena, Mesnil Romain et al. (2024-11)
    Toward 3D Printable Low-Carbon Mortar:
    Method and Application
  6. Bono Victor, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Mesnil Romain, Caron Jean-François (2024-09)
    Tailored Low-Carbon Footprint Cementitious Material for 3D Printing:
    Strategies for Rheology Adjustment and Mechanical Performance Estimation
  7. Farra Ramzi, Mazanec Oliver, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Mallet Alban (2024-09)
    Toward the Optimal Use of Local Cementitious Materials Through Novel Admixture-Technology and a Dedicated 2K-Printing-System
  8. Perrot Arnaud, Jacquet Yohan, Caron Jean-François, Mesnil Romain et al. (2024-08)
    Snapshot on 3D Printing with Alternative Binders and Materials:
    Earth, Geopolymers, Gypsum and Low-Carbon Concrete
  9. Bono Victor, Mesnil Romain, Ducoulombier Nicolas, Caron Jean-François (2024-08)
    Design, Structural Optimization and Fabrication of Concrete Shell Through Fiber-Reinforced 3D Printing

BibTeX
@article{bono_duco_mesn_caro.2024.MfFLCPMTPPO,
  author            = "Victor de Bono and Nicolas Ducoulombier and Romain Mesnil and Jean-François Caron",
  title             = "Methodology for Formulating Low-Carbon Printable Mortar Through Particles-Packing-Optimization",
  doi               = "10.1016/j.cemconres.2023.107403",
  year              = "2024",
  journal           = "Cement and Concrete Research",
  volume            = "176",
  pages             = "107403",
}
Formatted Citation

V. de Bono, N. Ducoulombier, R. Mesnil and J.-F. Caron, “Methodology for Formulating Low-Carbon Printable Mortar Through Particles-Packing-Optimization”, Cement and Concrete Research, vol. 176, p. 107403, 2024, doi: 10.1016/j.cemconres.2023.107403.

Bono, Victor de, Nicolas Ducoulombier, Romain Mesnil, and Jean-François Caron. “Methodology for Formulating Low-Carbon Printable Mortar Through Particles-Packing-Optimization”. Cement and Concrete Research 176 (2024): 107403. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2023.107403.